It was not always easy.
She wanted to know whether Mitchell had acknowledged his conduct. She wanted to know whether the older complaints had been handled properly. She wanted to know who had written the closing summaries and why the department had apparently failed to preserve a complete record of its own decisions.
But wanting answers did not give her the right to bypass the process.
So she continued with the work she was authorized to do and allowed the designated investigators to handle the complaint.
Late that afternoon, Sergeant Reeves arrived at the internal affairs office carrying his own notebook. He had reviewed the body-camera footage again before the meeting, this time paying particular attention to the moments before Mitchell's tone changed.
Harris invited him to sit.
"Let's begin with your arrival," Harris said. "What did you observe?"
"Officer Mitchell was standing near the front steps. Ms. Brooks was on the porch. She appeared calm. She was asking why she was being required to identify herself."
"Did you hear any threats from her?"
"No."
"Did you observe any physical aggression?"
"No."
"Did you have any reason to believe she had committed a crime?"
"Not based on what I saw when I arrived."
"What did Mitchell tell you?"
"He said there had been a suspicious-person call and that the woman was refusing to cooperate."
"Did he explain what specific conduct made her suspicious?"
"Not in any detail."
"Did you ask him?"
"Yes. I asked what the caller had reported and whether there was any indication of a crime."
"What was his response?"
"He said he was trying to determine who she was."
Harris looked down at the notes.
"Did you believe he had sufficient grounds to compel her to identify herself?"
"No."
The answer came without hesitation.
"Why?"
"Because we didn't have enough facts. A vague complaint about someone standing outside a residence doesn't automatically establish reasonable suspicion of criminal activity. And once I saw that the person was on the porch and was calmly asking questions, I didn't see a reason to escalate the encounter."
"Did you tell Officer Mitchell that?"
"I told him that she was free to go inside."
"Did he object?"
"He said she was being difficult."
"How did you respond?"
"I told him that a person asking questions isn't necessarily being difficult. Sometimes they're trying to understand what is happening."
Harris wrote down the statement.
"Looking back at the recording, is there anything you believe you should have done differently?"
Reeves took a breath.
"I could have asked Mitchell to step away from the porch and speak with me privately. That might have reduced the tension. I could also have made a more complete note of the exchange in my own report."
"Did you believe at the time that his conduct required immediate intervention?"
"I believed the encounter needed to end. I didn't have enough information to determine whether it required a formal complaint, but I knew the situation wasn't going anywhere productive."
"Did you review the body-camera footage that day?"
"No. I reviewed it after I learned that an administrative inquiry had been opened."
"Why didn't you review it earlier?"
"I didn't know a complaint had been made until afterward. My initial involvement was limited to the call for backup."
Harris nodded.
"Did you know about the earlier complaints involving Mitchell?"
"I knew he had been the subject of at least one complaint. I don't remember seeing the actual file."
"Did you know that some of those complaints described behavior similar to what occurred on Ms. Brooks's porch?"
"No."
"Would that information have affected how you responded?"
Reeves thought carefully before answering.
"It might have made me more concerned that this wasn't an isolated problem. But I would still need to look at the facts of each case. A previous complaint doesn't prove a new allegation. It does, however, mean we should pay attention to whether similar concerns are recurring."
Harris leaned back.
"That's an important distinction."
The interview continued into questions about supervisory practices, report writing, and the procedures for notifying supervisors when an encounter became contentious. Reeves answered candidly. He admitted that officers sometimes used the word uncooperative too casually, and that the term could become a shortcut for describing a person who simply did not respond as the officer expected.
"That concerns me," Harris said.
"It should," Reeves replied. "If an officer writes that someone was uncooperative, a reviewer ought to ask what the person actually did. Did they interfere with an investigation? Did they threaten someone? Or did they simply decline to answer a question? Those are very different things."
Harris looked up.
"Has that distinction been emphasized in training?"
"Yes, but I don't know whether everyone applies it consistently."
"Do you think the department has relied too heavily on an officer's description when reviewing complaints?"
Reeves hesitated.