"Would that be an adequate review?"
"No," Lawson said quietly. "Not if the recording was necessary to answer the allegation."
The answer was important, but Harris did not treat it as a confession of wrongdoing.
"Peter, do you remember anyone instructing you to close complaints quickly or avoid reviewing recordings?"
"No one ever told me to ignore evidence."
"Did anyone pressure you to reduce the backlog?"
"Yes. We were frequently told to bring the backlog down. That was not unusual. We had limited staff, and administrative work accumulated quickly."
"Was there a specific target?"
"Sometimes there were targets for how many open cases we needed to review each week. I don't remember the exact numbers."
"Did those targets affect how you handled complaints?"
Lawson considered the question.
"They affected how much time we could spend on each file. Whether that affected the quality of the decisions is something I have to think about."
"Did the department measure the number of complaints closed more consistently than the quality of the reviews?"
Lawson let out a slow breath.
"I think we measured completion more easily than quality."
The room fell silent.
Harris wrote the statement in his notes.
"What would have happened if you found a complaint difficult to resolve because the evidence was incomplete?"
"I should have returned it for additional work or documented why the evidence wasn't available."
"Was that always done?"
"No."
"Why not?"
"Sometimes the person reviewing the case believed the officer's report was sufficient. Sometimes the complaint seemed minor. Sometimes there wasn't a clear process for tracking missing evidence. And sometimes, frankly, people were tired and trying to get through their workload."
"Do you believe those are acceptable reasons to close an incomplete complaint?"
"No," Lawson said. "They're explanations. They aren't necessarily justifications."
Harris leaned back slightly.
"That distinction is useful."
Lawson looked at the old summary again.
"I want to make something clear. I never wanted complaints to disappear. I spent years telling officers that they had to document what they did. But I may have accepted documentation that was less complete than it should have been."
"Would you be willing to provide a written statement describing the review practices you remember?"
"Yes. I'll need to distinguish what I know from what I'm recalling generally."
"That's exactly what we need."
The interview lasted another hour. Lawson described how complaints were routed, how supervisors reviewed dispositions, and how the department's administrative workload had grown faster than the staff assigned to manage it. He could not establish whether he had personally watched the missing recording, and he refused to claim that he had.
Before leaving, he paused near the conference room door.
"Lieutenant, can I ask you something?"
"Of course."
"Is this because the woman on the porch has a position with the state?"
Harris answered carefully.
"Her position is one reason we're taking precautions to protect the integrity of the process. But the questions about the older files arise from the records themselves. The same review would be necessary if the person who filed the complaint had no professional connection to the state at all."
Lawson nodded slowly.
"I hope that's true."
"So do I."
After Lawson left, Harris added a note to the file. The interview had identified a possible weakness in the department's complaint-review process, but it had not established whether Lawson had violated a specific rule in the case under examination. That question would require a more complete record.
The investigation was becoming more complicated, but it was also becoming more precise.
The team was beginning to separate three questions that had previously been treated as one.
First, had Mitchell acted appropriately during the encounter?
Second, had the department investigated earlier complaints involving similar behavior in a reasonable and documented manner?
Third, did the department's administrative practices make it too easy for incomplete investigations to be marked as resolved?
The answers might overlap, but they were not interchangeable. An officer could violate policy even if the department's review system worked properly. A complaint could be inadequately investigated even if the original allegation could not ultimately be proven. And a department could have a flawed administrative process without every person involved deliberately trying to conceal misconduct.
Harris intended to keep those distinctions clear.
That afternoon, the records administrator called again.
"We have access to the archived storage now," she said. "The system administrator has located the original file associated with the older complaint."
"Is the recording playable?"
"Yes, but we're verifying its integrity before providing it to investigators. We want to make sure the file hasn't been altered during migration."
"How long will that take?"
"We should have a verified copy tomorrow morning."
"Please preserve the original and provide the verification report with the copy."
"Understood."
Harris ended the call and sat quietly.
For the first time, the investigation had a realistic chance of examining one of the missing recordings rather than merely documenting its absence.