The department had to investigate its own officer without interference from her.
Her office had to examine the department's broader practices without giving her personal experience special weight.
And the public had to be able to trust that the eventual conclusions rested on evidence rather than professional connections.
That was a difficult balance.
But it was the only balance worth defending.
By noon, Lieutenant Harris had located the three previous complaint files.
The first was stored in the department's current records system.
The second had been archived during a software migration.
The third was contained in a separate administrative folder that had not been linked to Mitchell's personnel record.
Harris placed the documents side by side.
The similarities were immediately noticeable.
Each complaint involved a civilian who said Mitchell had approached them without clearly explaining the reason for his presence or the basis for his questions.
Each complaint also contained a brief statement from the officer describing the civilian as uncooperative.
The first file had been closed after a supervisor concluded that there was insufficient evidence to substantiate misconduct.
The second had been marked resolved after an informal discussion with the officer.
The third had been closed after a short administrative review.
None contained a complete record of the evidence considered.
Harris read each summary carefully.
He was not prepared to conclude that the complaints were valid. People could misunderstand police encounters, and officers could make reasonable decisions that others disliked.
But he was equally unwilling to accept that the complaints had been handled properly simply because someone had marked them resolved.
He began searching for the names of the supervisors associated with each case.
The first had been reviewed by a sergeant who had since retired.
The second had been assigned to a lieutenant who now worked in another division.
The third had been signed by a supervisor who still served in the department.
Harris made a note of each name.
Then he opened the personnel system to check whether the complaints had been considered during Mitchell's annual performance reviews.
The answer was unclear.
One review mentioned the importance of professional communication with members of the public. Another contained no reference to complaints at all.
The third indicated that Mitchell had completed a refresher course on civilian interactions, but it did not explain why the training had been recommended or whether the department had evaluated its effectiveness.
Harris leaned back.
There were several possible explanations for the gaps.
The records might have been incomplete because the department's systems were poorly organized. Some documents might have been stored in locations no one had checked. Supervisors might have made decisions based on conversations that were never adequately documented.
Those possibilities were concerning, but they were not equivalent to deliberate misconduct.
Harris needed to establish which explanation fit the evidence.
He opened a new document and began preparing interview questions.
The first person he contacted was the retired sergeant who had reviewed the earliest complaint.
The sergeant agreed to speak with him the following morning.
The second person, now assigned to a regional operations unit, said he would check his calendar.
The third supervisor responded almost immediately.
I remember the case. It was minor and did not warrant a formal investigation.
Harris read the response carefully.
Then he typed a reply.
Please provide the factual basis for that assessment and identify any records or interviews considered before the complaint was closed.
He sent the email and waited.
The reply did not come.
Instead, Harris received a telephone call from Chief Holloway.
"How is the review progressing?"
"I've located the three files. They're incomplete, and I'm working to determine why."
"Do you have any evidence that the complaints were mishandled?"
"I have evidence that the documentation is insufficient to establish how they were handled."
"Isn't that the same thing?"
"No, Chief. It means we can't verify that the process was followed. We still need to determine whether the work wasn't done or whether the records are missing."
Holloway paused.
"How long will that take?"
"I expect to have a clearer picture after the interviews."
"All right. Keep me informed."
After the call, Harris returned to his computer.
He knew the chief wanted answers quickly, but rushing to a conclusion would undermine the investigation.
The department needed to establish what happened during the original encounter, why Mitchell had described the resident as suspicious, and whether the previous complaints revealed a recurring problem.
Those were three related but distinct questions.
They might eventually point toward the same conclusion.
Or they might reveal that the current incident had been poorly handled while the earlier complaints were unrelated or inadequately documented for entirely different reasons.
Until the evidence was examined, neither possibility could be ruled out.
Harris opened the department's digital evidence archive and searched for recordings associated with the three earlier complaints.
The first search returned no results.