The Cops Tried To Arrest A Black Woman On Her Own Porch — Then Learned She Was The U.S. Attorney

Chapter 16

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Holloway studied him.

"You're right."

It was a reluctant admission, but Reeves recognized it for what it was.

The chief had not built his career by refusing to change his mind. He had built it by making difficult decisions, and he understood that sometimes a difficult decision meant accepting information he would rather not have received.

"There's another issue," Reeves said.

He opened the final section of the folder.

"During my review of Mitchell's records, I found three previous civilian complaints involving similar concerns."

Holloway's eyes narrowed.

"Three?"

"Yes, sir."

"What were they about?"

"The first involved a resident questioned outside an apartment building. The second involved a woman who said Mitchell demanded identification while she was walking toward her vehicle. The third concerned a traffic stop near a private driveway."

"Were the complaints substantiated?"

"The records don't provide enough information to determine that."

"How can that be?"

"The files are incomplete. Some contain only a brief summary and a final disposition. I couldn't find supporting witness statements or clear documentation of whether the available recordings were reviewed."

Holloway stared at the folder.

"Who closed those cases?"

"I'm still trying to establish that."

"Why wasn't this brought to my attention before?"

"I don't know, Chief. That's one of the questions we need to answer."

The chief slowly closed the folder.

For the first time during the meeting, he appeared genuinely unsettled.

He had expected to discuss an uncomfortable interaction and determine whether an officer needed additional training or counseling.

Instead, he was looking at the possibility that earlier complaints had been closed without adequate documentation.

If that was true, the issue extended beyond Mitchell.

Someone had received those complaints. Someone had reviewed them, or had decided not to review them. Someone had entered a final disposition into the system.

And the department had accepted that disposition without ensuring that the underlying work could be verified.

"How far back do the records go?" Holloway asked.

"The earliest complaint is approximately two years old."

"Request the complete files."

"I already have."

"Good. I want internal affairs involved."

"I've copied the supervisor on the request."

Holloway nodded, then looked at the clock.

"All right. We'll proceed with the review. Keep it confidential to the extent our procedures permit, and make sure Mitchell receives a fair opportunity to respond."

"Of course."

"And Daniel?"

Reeves paused.

"I want a report that tells me what happened, not what anyone thinks I want to hear."

The sergeant met his eyes.

"That's what you'll get."

When Reeves left the office, Holloway remained seated for several minutes.

He opened his computer and searched for the most recent departmental policy concerning civilian complaints.

The policy was clear. Every complaint was supposed to be logged, assessed, and assigned an appropriate disposition. When the available information suggested a possible violation, the department was expected to conduct a review proportionate to the allegation.

The procedures were not perfect, but they existed for a reason.

Holloway opened another file containing the department's annual performance summary.

The number of complaints had decreased over the previous two years.

He had cited that statistic during public meetings, describing it as evidence that community relations were improving.

Now he wondered whether the number represented an actual improvement or simply reflected the way complaints had been categorized and closed.

A falling number could indicate better policing.

It could also indicate that fewer people were willing to complain, that reports were being recorded inconsistently, or that the system was failing to capture the full picture.

The number alone could not answer the question.

Holloway picked up the telephone.

"Please ask Lieutenant Harris to come to my office."

A few minutes later, Lieutenant Marcus Harris entered.

Harris had served as the department's internal affairs supervisor for four years. He was meticulous, reserved, and known for keeping his opinions to himself until he had examined the evidence.

"Good morning, Chief."

"Good morning. Have a seat."

Harris sat down.

"I need you to review three civilian complaints involving Officer Ryan Mitchell. Sergeant Reeves has requested the complete records."

Harris's expression remained composed.

"All three?"

"Yes."

"Is this related to yesterday's incident?"

"It may be. We need to establish whether the earlier cases were handled appropriately."

Harris nodded.

"I'll review them."

"I also want you to examine the complaint-handling process itself. Determine whether the files are incomplete because documents were never created, because they were stored elsewhere, or because records were lost during a system migration."

"Understood."

Holloway paused.

"This review needs to be independent. If you find that a supervisor made a mistake, document it. If you find that the procedures were followed correctly, document that too."

Harris looked at him.

"Are you concerned that someone interfered with the earlier investigations?"

"I'm concerned that we don't yet know what happened."

"That's fair."

Harris rose.

"I'll begin immediately."

After he left, Holloway looked again at the report on his desk.

News in the same category

The Cops Tried To Arrest A Black Woman On Her Own Porch — Then Learned She Was The U.S. Attorney

45 Part