He watched the arrival of the second unit, listened to the exchange between Mitchell and Grant, and noted the exact point at which Danielle was told she was free to return inside.
When the recording ended, he removed his glasses and rubbed his eyes.
The incident was more troubling than he had initially believed.
Yet the most important question remained unanswered.
Why had Mitchell approached the situation with such certainty that the woman on the porch did not belong there?
Was it simply a poor judgment call?
Had he received additional information that was not included in the dispatch recording?
Or had he allowed an assumption about Danielle to shape his behavior before he had established any facts?
Reeves did not know.
And he would not pretend to know until he had examined the evidence.
He saved his notes and prepared a request for Mitchell's written statement.
Then he opened the department's records system and searched for previous incidents involving the officer.
The system returned several entries.
Most were routine reports, traffic stops, and calls for assistance.
But three entries had been categorized as civilian complaints.
Reeves opened the first.
It concerned an encounter with a resident who had been questioned outside an apartment building. The complaint had been marked as resolved after a brief supervisory review.
He opened the second.
That complaint involved a woman who said Mitchell had demanded identification while she was walking toward her own vehicle. The record contained a short summary but no attached witness statements.
The third complaint was less than six months old.
A resident had alleged that Mitchell became hostile after being asked why he had stopped a vehicle parked in a private driveway.
The disposition field contained a single phrase.
No further action required.
Reeves stared at the screen.
Three complaints did not establish a pattern of misconduct. Each incident would need to be examined individually, and there might be legitimate explanations for some of the decisions made.
But three complaints involving similar concerns deserved more attention than a cursory glance.
He opened the details of the most recent case and searched for the supporting documents.
There were none.
No interview notes.
No attached witness statements.
No record of whether the officer's body-camera footage had been reviewed.
Only a short administrative summary and the final disposition.
Reeves leaned back in his chair.
He remembered the chief's instructions.
Do not make assumptions about Officer Mitchell's intentions.
That was reasonable advice.
But the same standard had to apply to the department itself.
They could not assume that an earlier complaint had been handled properly simply because the system marked it as closed.
Nor could they assume that the absence of further action meant there had been nothing to investigate.
The records were incomplete.
And incomplete records could conceal both innocent mistakes and serious failures.
Reeves looked at the clock.
It was nearly ten thirty.
He should have gone home an hour earlier, but now he knew that the preliminary review would require more work than he had expected.
He drafted a memorandum requesting the complete files for all three complaints, including any archived correspondence, supervisory notes, and recordings that might still exist.
He copied the department's internal affairs supervisor on the request.
Then he sent it.
For a moment, he watched the confirmation appear on his screen.
He knew that the request might make some people uncomfortable.
It might even create tension with Mitchell, who would undoubtedly feel that his earlier work was being scrutinized unfairly.
But Reeves had no intention of treating the officer as guilty before the investigation was complete.
He simply wanted to know whether the department had done what it was supposed to do.
If the earlier complaints had been properly investigated, the records should demonstrate that.
If they had not, the department needed to understand why.
He closed the database and gathered his belongings.
As he walked toward the exit, his phone vibrated.
A message had arrived from Chief Holloway.
Please meet with me at 8:00 a.m. tomorrow. We need to discuss the preliminary findings and determine the appropriate next steps.
Reeves read it twice.
He typed a short response confirming that he would attend.
Then he stepped outside into the cool night air.
Across Willow Creek, Danielle Brooks was asleep in her home, unaware that the first review of the evidence had revealed discrepancies between the original dispatch and the officer's written report.
She did not know that earlier complaints involving Mitchell had been located.
And she had no idea that the department's leadership was preparing for a meeting that could change the direction of the investigation.
But the events of the morning had already begun to produce consequences.
The body-camera footage existed.
The dispatch recording existed.
The witnesses existed.
And for the first time, someone inside the department was looking beyond the official summary to examine what had actually happened.
The truth was no longer dependent on a single officer's description of the encounter.