They were quiet then, and the workshop was quiet, and the light from the window fell across the bench, and Naomi sat on the stool with her hands folded in her lap, and Asa Hollis stood on the other side of the bench, and she waited for him to say what he would say, and she thought about how she had come here to tell him the truth, and how she had told it, and how the truth was a simple thing, and how simple things are sometimes the hardest to carry, and she waited.
Asa Hollis put his hands on the bench, and he looked at her, and he said, "Miss Falk, the chair is mine to give."
## ter 5 — The Truth He Told
Asa Hollis stood on the other side of the bench, and he looked at Naomi Falk sitting on the stool with her hands folded in her lap, and he looked at the board he had been planing, and he looked at the window at the far end of the workshop, and the light came through it and fell across the bench, and he thought about the chair by the window at the boarding house, and about the year and a half it had stood empty, and about the evening Naomi had sat in it, and he knew what he would tell her, and he knew he had waited long enough to tell it.
"Miss Falk," he said, "you have told me the truth, and now I will tell you the truth, and the truth is about the chair."
Naomi looked at him, and she did not speak, and Asa put his hands on the bench, and he began.
"The chair by the window was my mother's," he said. "Her name was Faith, and she sat in it every evening, with her mending in her lap, and she looked out of the window while she worked, and she watched the street, and she watched the light change, and she said the window was the best place in the house, because from the window you could see the whole town, and the whole sky, and you could see the weather coming before it came."
He stopped, and he looked at the window, and Naomi waited, and he went on.
"My mother died in the winter of 1877," he said. "She was ill for a month, and the cold was hard that winter, and she died in her sleep, and I buried her in the churchyard, and the chair stood empty, and I did not know what to do with it, and I left it where it was, by the window, and I went on with my work, and the winter went on, and the spring came."
Naomi listened, and she thought about her own mother, and about the winter after Peter died, and about how a house feels when someone is gone from it, and how the rooms keep their shape, and how the chairs keep their places, and how the empty places are the hardest to look at, and she did not speak, and Asa went on.
"In the spring of 1878, I took the chair apart, and I made it again, of oak, so it would last," Asa said. "I cut the oak myself, and I planed it, and I joined it, and I sanded it until it was smooth, and I set it back by the window, in my mother's place, and I thought it would stand there empty, and I thought that was how it would be."
He stopped again, and he wiped his hands on his apron, and he looked at Naomi, and he said, "And then Grace came."
Naomi looked at him, and Asa said, "Grace came to Ash Hollow in the spring of 1878, and she was new here, and she did not know anyone, and she came to supper at the boarding house on her first evening, and the table was full, and the chair by the window was empty, and she sat in it, because it was the only empty chair, and because no one told her it belonged to anyone."
Naomi felt her breath catch, and Asa went on, and his voice was steady, and his hands were still on the bench.
"She sat in it, and she ate her supper, and she looked out of the window, and she did not know it had been my mother's chair, and she did not know my mother had died, and she did not know any of it," Asa said. "And I looked at her, and I said nothing, because my mother's words were in my ears, and I have carried them ever since."
"What words?" Naomi asked, and her voice was quiet.