He stopped, and the workshop was quiet, and the light from the window fell across the bench, and Naomi sat on the stool with her hands folded in her lap, and she waited, and Asa said, "I said nothing because my mother's words were in my ears. 'Let whoever needs the window seat have it.' That is what she said, and that is what Grace lived by, and that is what I live by, and that is why the chair has always belonged to the next woman who needed the window."
Naomi wiped her eyes with the back of her hand, and she said, "Tell me about Grace."
Asa looked at her, and he was quiet for a moment, and then he said, "Grace was twenty years old when she came to Ash Hollow, and she had come from the east, and she had no family here, and she took a room at the boarding house, and she worked at the grocer's shop, and she was quick, and she was kind, and she laughed easily, and she sat in the chair by the window every evening, and she mended her dresses there, and she looked out of the window, and she watched the street, and she watched the light change, and she said the window was the best place in the house."
He stopped, and he looked at the board on the bench, and he said, "She sat there through twelve winters, and she folded her shawl on the back of the chair every evening, and the shawl was blue wool, and she had made it herself, and she wore it when the evenings were cold, and she folded it when the evenings were warm, and it lay on the back of the chair, and it has lain there since the spring of 1890, and I have not moved it, and I have not touched it, because it was hers, and because moving it felt like moving her."
Naomi thought about the shawl, and about how she had moved it aside, carefully, and put it back where she found it, and she said, "I moved it. I am sorry."
"You moved it gently," Asa said. "And you put it back. Grace would not have minded that. She was not a woman who minded small things. She minded whether a person was kind, and whether a person told the truth, and whether a person kept their word, and those are the things that matter, and you have done all three, Miss Falk. You came here, and you told me the truth, and you told it plainly, and that is what matters."
Naomi looked at him, and she said, "Tell me about the year and a half."
Asa was quiet, and he looked at the window, and the light was lower now, and it fell across the bench in a long, gold band, and he said, "The year and a half was long. The chair stood empty, and the shawl lay on the back of it, and the supper table was quiet, and I ate my supper and I looked at the chair, and I thought about Grace, and I thought about my mother, and I thought about the words, and I did not understand them, not really, until the evening you sat in the chair."
"What did you understand?" Naomi asked.
Asa looked at her, and he said, "I understood that the chair was never Grace's to keep. It was my mother's to give, and it was Grace's to sit in, and it was mine to give, and it has always belonged to the next woman who needed the window. My mother needed the window, and then Grace needed the window, and now you need the window, and that is how it has always been, and that is how it will always be."
Naomi sat still, and the workshop was quiet, and the shavings lay still on the floor, and the light from the window fell across the bench, and Asa came around the bench, and he stood in front of her, and he looked at her, and he said, "Miss Falk, you may keep sitting there."
Naomi looked up at him, and tears came to her eyes again, and she said, "Mr. Hollis, I do not know what to say."
"Say you will sit there," Asa said. "Say you will sit by the window, and look out at the street, and watch the light change, and that is enough."