She thought about Peter, then, sitting in the chair by the window with the rain on the glass behind her. She thought about the house they had kept together, and the winters they had spent in it, and the way he had told her to go on, and to live, and to find work that mattered, and she thought about how the school in Ash Hollow was the keeping of that promise, and how the chair was the place where she sat at the end of each day, and how the chair had never been hers to keep, and how it had never been anyone's to keep, and how it had always been a seat for whoever needed the window, and how Asa had given it to her, and how she would keep it for as long as she needed it, and how one day she would give it on, the way it had been given to her, and how that was the way of it, and how that was enough.
She thought about Grace, too, sitting in this same chair for twelve years, and about Faith, sitting in it before Grace, and about how both of them had been new once, and how both of them had sat in the empty chair on their first day, and how the town had talked then, too, or so Hilda had told her, and how the talk had died then, and how it would die now, and how the chair would go on standing by the window, long after all of them were gone, waiting for whoever needed it next. She thought about how strange it was, that a chair could hold so much, and how it was not strange at all, because a chair was not only wood and joints, but the hands that had made it, and the people who had sat in it, and the words that had been said over it, and the quiet evenings it had kept, and she was glad, suddenly and sharply, to be sitting in it, and to be part of that, and to be, for an hour, at home in a town that had not been her home a month before.
The evening wore on. The children grew sleepy, and the mothers gathered them up, and the men stood and talked by the door, and the women cleared the dishes, and the lamps burned lower still, and Naomi sat in the chair by the window, and she did not move, and she did not need to move, because the chair was hers to sit in, for as long as she needed it, and because Asa had given it, and because the town had heard him say so, and because the talk had stopped, and because the supper had gone on, and because the rain was falling outside, and the hall was warm, and the window was dark, and the chair held her, and that was enough. And Naomi sat in the chair by the window at the church supper, and the evening went on around her, and the window looked out on the rain, and the seat was hers, and she stayed.
Asa Hollis found the loose leg on a Thursday, late in the autumn, when the light came in low through the windows of the boarding house and the air smelled of woodsmoke and apples. He had come to the boarding house to fix a shutter that had worked loose in the wind, and Hilda Berg had asked him to stay for supper, and after supper he had gone to move the table back against the wall, the way he always did when the meal was done, and his hand had caught the back of the chair by the window, and the chair had rocked under his hand, just a little, just enough for him to feel it. He stopped. He set his hand on the chair again, and he pressed down, gently, and the chair rocked again, a small, uneven rocking, the kind of rocking that meant a joint had worked loose. He bent down and looked at the front leg on the right side, and he saw the gap where the leg met the seat, a thin dark line where the wood had pulled away from the wood, and he ran his thumb along it, and he knew what it was. The chair was thirteen years old. He had built it in the autumn of 1878, in the year he married Grace, and thirteen years of sitting,