Hilda stood with the dish towel in her hands, and she did not know what to say. She had expected Naomi to agree. She had expected the matter to be settled by supper, and the chair to stand empty by tomorrow, and the talk to die, and the house to be quiet. She had not expected this: a quiet refusal, given without heat, and without pride, and without any room in it for argument, the way a door is shut without slamming.
"Naomi," she said, "the town will not let it rest. You know how this town is. They will talk, and the talk will grow, and it will come to the church supper on Saturday, and it will be worse there, in front of everyone."
"I know," Naomi said. "I have heard the talk, in small ways. A look at the school gate. A cool word at the market. I have heard it. And I will still keep the seat, because it was given to me, and because to give it back now would be to say that it was wrong to sit in it, and it was not wrong. It was empty, and I sat in it, and Asa has given it to me, and that is the end of it."
Hilda looked at her, and she saw the tiredness in Naomi's face, and the resolve under it, and she thought about how Naomi was a widow, and how she had come a long way to teach in a town where she knew no one, and how she had sat in the chair on her first evening because it was empty, and how she had gone to Asa herself, and told him the truth, and how Asa had given her the seat, and how none of that mattered to the town, because the town did not see the truth of a thing. The town saw the shape of a thing, and the shape of this thing was a new woman sitting in a dead woman's chair, and no amount of truth would change the shape of it, and Hilda knew that, and she worried, and she worried more now than she had worried that morning, because now she saw that the matter would not be settled by a small change of seat, and that it would go on, and that it would come to the church supper on Saturday, and that she could not stop it.
"Will you at least think about it?" Hilda asked, and she heard the pleading in her own voice, and she did not like it.
"I have thought about it," Naomi said, gently. "I thought about it before I went to Asa, and I thought about it after, and I am thinking about it now. And my answer is the same. I will keep the seat."
She picked up a dish then, and she began to dry it, as if the conversation were over, and as if the drying of a dish were the most natural thing in the world, and Hilda stood and watched her, and she did not know whether to be angry or sorry, and she was a little of both, and mostly she was worried, because she could see the trouble coming now, the way you can see a storm coming over the ridge, and she could see that it would come to the church supper, and that there was nothing she could do to turn it aside.
That night, Hilda lay awake for a long time, listening to the house. She thought about the chair by the window, and about Grace sitting in it for twelve years, and about Faith sitting in it before Grace, and about Naomi sitting in it now, and about how she had kept this house peaceful for so long, and how she did not know whether she could keep it peaceful any longer. She thought about speaking to Asa, and she decided against it, because the chair was his, and the word about it was his to give. She thought about speaking to Naomi again, and she decided against that, too, because Naomi had given her answer, and it had been a quiet answer, and a final one.