And then she saw the chair. It stood at the head of the long table, by the window, and it was the oak chair from the boarding house, and she knew it at once, by the shape of its back, and by the way the light fell on the wood, and by the blue wool shawl folded on its back. Asa had carried it over that morning, and set it by the church window, and Naomi stood and looked at it, and she felt her heart beat hard, because the chair had been brought here, to this room, in front of the whole town, and she did not know whether it had been brought as a kindness or as a judgment, and she did not know what it meant, and she was afraid to ask.
Hilda saw it, too, and she stopped beside Naomi, and she said, very quietly, "He brought it himself. I saw him carry it down the street this morning, with the shawl folded over his arm." And Naomi said nothing, because there was nothing to say, and they went to their places, and they sat down at the long table, and the supper began.
The food was passed from hand to hand: the roast, and the potatoes, and the beans, and the bread, and the pies, and the talk went on around the tables, of the harvest, and of the weather, and of the new road, and of the winter coming, and Naomi ate, and she listened, and she waited, and she did not know what she was waiting for, only that she was waiting, and that the chair by the window stood empty at the head of the table, and that everyone in the room knew it stood empty, and that everyone in the room was waiting, too.
Asa sat at the far end of the long table, with the other men, and he ate quietly, and he said little, and Naomi watched him from where she sat, and she saw the sawdust still on his sleeve, from the morning's work, and she saw the way his hands rested on the table, and she thought about how those hands had made the chair, in 1878, fitting the joints tight and sanding the oak smooth, and how those hands had carried it down the street that morning, and set it by the window, and how she did not know what he meant by it, and how she would know soon enough, because the supper was going on, and the hour was coming, and she could feel it coming, the way one feels a change in the weather.
When the plates were cleared, and the pies were brought out, and the coffee was poured, Asa stood up. He did not raise his voice. He did not hurry. He stood at his place at the far end of the table, and he looked down the length of the room, and the talk died, the way talk dies when a man stands up who does not often stand up, and the room went quiet, and Naomi felt her hands go still in her lap, and she looked at him, and she waited.
"I have something to say," Asa said, "and I will say it plainly, and then I will sit down, and we will go on with our supper."
He spoke the way he worked: slowly, and carefully, and without waste. He said that the chair by the window was his, and that he had made it himself, with his own hands, in the year 1878, when he married Grace, and that before Grace it had been the chair of his mother, Faith Hollis, who had died in the winter of 1877, and that Grace had sat in it on her first day in Ash Hollow, in the spring of 1878, because it was the empty chair, and no one had told her otherwise, and that Grace had sat in it for twelve years, until she died of the fever in the spring of 1890, and that he had kept it empty for a year and a half after that, with the blue shawl folded on its back, and that Naomi Falk had come to Ash Hollow in the autumn, to