way the rider sat his horse, a looseness, a confidence, as if the saddle were a chair in a room he
owned. And once, as he crossed a patch of open sand, the sun struck something bright at his chest,
briefly, like a coin turning over. A star, she thought. A star, riding into this valley, on time and in
ignorance, with its saddlebags empty and its intentions full, toward a well where two men had been
sitting since Tuesday with a rifle in a tower. She lowered the glass and lay still in the growing heat
of the Apron and felt, in her ribs, not fear, and not pity either, but the first, unwelcome stirrings of a
responsibility she had not packed for. Wade Tillery was a fool, and in all likelihood a thief in the
process of deciding to become one, and there was no version of the papers sewn into her coat that
required her to save him from the arithmetic of his own choices. And yet he was riding, whistling
for all she knew, into men who did not whistle, and who had been placed there before she had told
a living soul she was coming, and whatever they did to the deputy they would do in her name, on
her road, as part of a bill that had been presented, originally, for her husband's signature in a survey
camp in March. She had not ridden forty miles to add another name to the stub of that torn-out
page. She checked the Spencer in its boot, though it was not in its boot; it was in her hands, where
it had been since the glass came down, and she could not have said when she had taken it out.
Below her the valley arranged itself in the new light, the well, the tower, the two horses, the one
visible man, the deputy small and bright and coming on. Somewhere in it, invisible as a held
breath, was a man on a muffled mule, who had left her water and a warning and no name, and
whose reasons were his own and had been since Tuesday, or since March, or since whenever his
part in this had begun, which was a question she intended, with some determination, to live long
enough to ask him. Hattie Beckett settled the carbine across the rock, not aiming at anything yet,
because aiming is a decision and she had not made hers, and she watched the road she had made
come, at last, to meet the road that had been made for her.
She decided the way Sam had taught her to decide about weather and about men, which was to
stop asking what she felt and ask instead what the ground required. The ground required that Wade
Tillery not ride the last two hundred yards with his hat in the sun and his mind on breakfast. It
required, further, that the man in the tower understand, before anything else happened, that he was
seen. Hattie settled her cheek along the Spencer's stock, found the great fallen wheel at the top of
the tower where it leaned against the platform rail like a broken halo, and put her first shot through
its hub. The wheel shuddered. A spoke cracked with a sound like a dry branch stepped on in an
empty church. The man behind it came up out of his shade so fast that his hat stayed where he had
been, and for one bright second his whole face, young and startled and already angry, was offered
to the morning, and Hattie, who had shot squirrels off fences at forty paces for the pot, lowered the
carbine two inches and fired again and took the hat clean off the rail and sent it sailing down into
the corral, where it landed in the dust at the feet of the two waiting horses and lay there like a small,
dark, reproachful animal.
Then she stood up. It was, she knew, the most dangerous thing she had done in two days. She
stood up on the crest of the Apron with the sun behind her and the carbine across her body, not
raised, and she filled her lungs with the thin, hot air of the valley and she called out, in the voice
that had once held forty children in one room through a thunderstorm and a broken window, "Wade
Tillery! Get off that horse and get behind your animal, and do it now, because the man in that tower
has been paid to watch this road and you are riding into his breakfast!"
The deputy, to do him the only justice the morning would ever quite manage, did not waste time
asking how she knew his name or why a widow was standing on a hill with a carbine ordering him
about like a schoolyard. Something in the voice, or something in the two shots still ringing in the
basalt, reached the part of him that had been trained, however lightly, by men who had survived
worse mornings than this. He went out of the saddle on the far side of his horse in one motion,
dragged the animal by main force into the lee of a boulder at the track's edge, and had his revolver
out and his hat off and his face in the dirt before the echo of her voice had finished travelling the