sealed parcel, brown paper, wax, her own hand on the direction, under a name that belonged to an
Ohio schoolroom. "Yours, I believe," he said. "Unopened. Unguessed at, I will have you know, by a
man who has thought about it every day since September with a diligence the church would call
sinful. Whatever theatre you have arranged for us, Hattie, I trust it is worth two men's autumns."
"It had better be, Elias," Hattie said. "I have run out of summers to spend on it."
Judge Henry A. Corwin received her at noon, in chambers, because Whitcomb had gone ahead
with a note and because Corwin, who had ridden circuit in that territory since before the war that
made it a territory, had the old judge's instinct for the case that arrives smelling of river water and
gun oil: it is either nothing at all, or it is the kind that, ignored, follows a man into his obituaries. He
was seventy, white-whiskered, deaf in the left ear and consequently in absolute command of every
conversation conducted to his right, and he listened to Hattie Beckett for twenty minutes without
once interrupting, while the packet from her coat lining lay on his blotter in its layers - field-book
leaves, duplicate plat, affidavit - and beside it, in its own oilcloth, the shirt, still folded, which he
did not ask her to open, having read, in the way of his trade, the sentence it constituted.
"The cap," he said at last.
She set it on the blotter between them, brass, fire-darkened, the file's bright scoring across its
face and the stamped number up. Corwin took a glass from his drawer and read it the way another
man reads a face. He turned it over. He turned it back. "I have hanged a man on less metal than
this," he said, conversationally, "and acquitted on more, so do not fall in love with it, Mrs. Beckett.
But I will tell you what I see, as a courtesy to the road you have ridden. I see an object that has
never been in the earth it describes - which is precisely its testimony, since the filed plat swears it
was set and sworn. The other one, when it comes - and it will come, in a box, with a clerk, shining -
will be the first exhibit in this territory's history to have been manufactured by its own paperwork.
What I cannot yet do, madam, is hang a survey, a murder, and what smells to me remarkably like a
conspiracy of half the officeholders of Las Palomas County on a widow's affidavit and a dying
chainman's errand, however well sewn. The chainman is the case. You understand that. Everything
you carry is corroboration of a man. It is not the man."
"He will be here tomorrow, Judge," Hattie said. "Carried, if the doctor's orders hold sway over
the patient's, which history does not support. What I am asking today is not a verdict. I am asking
that this court take notice, today, before you leave Socorro, that these papers exist and are lodged -
because papers that are merely carried by a widow on a river road have a way of becoming, in the
official record, papers that never were. I have watched one inquest be written in Las Palomas out of
a body nobody examined. I did not ride forty miles and cross a flood on a ferry flat to furnish the
territory with a second."
Corwin was silent a moment, and then he did the thing she had ridden for, with a pen, in a hand
like a ploughshare, in a docket book the clerk brought at his gesture: he wrote the date, and the
hour, and the words received and lodged, and an inventory of the packet in his own writing, item by
item, down to the cap and its number, which he read aloud as he wrote it, so that the room itself
was a witness. "There," he said. "It exists, Mrs. Beckett, in a book that travels with me and sleeps in
my valise, and a clerk in Las Palomas would have to misfile me to misfile it. Court will sit
tomorrow at nine, an hour before I was to leave this town, and it will sit on your petition, and the
chainman will be sworn if the doctor permits it and carried in like artillery if he does not. Deputy."
His eye had gone, with a marksman's unhurried travel, to Tillery, who stood by the door with his
hat in his hands and his star still crooked from the white country. "You will consider yourself this
court's officer for the keeping of that witness, since you appear to have appointed yourself to the
duty somewhere along a river. And you will straighten that star, Deputy, before you come into my
court. A crooked star in a courtroom is an argument, and I allow only the arguments I have
subpoenaed."
It reached them, as the countermove in such affairs always does, not at the speed of a horse but
at the speed of a wire, which is to say it had been in Socorro before they were. The clerk who had
carried the docket book out carried, on his return, an expression that men in his trade practise for
fires and bereavements, and a sheaf of paper still warm from the telegraph office's urgency, and he
laid it before the judge with the care of a man setting down something that might be loaded. Corwin