service will be the escort of the prisoners this day produces, to Santa Fe, at a deputy's wage, every
dollar of which this court will direct to be receipted against your notes in the hands of the receiver I
am about to appoint over the First Bank of Las Palomas, whose affairs will bear, and will receive,
an examination. You will pay, Deputy. Let no man leave this room saying Wade Tillery was
forgiven his debts for turning witness: that is Las Palomas arithmetic, and we are done with it. You
will pay at the honest rate, in the open, and when the last receipt is signed you will be, for the first
time since you pinned that star on, a man whose credit is his own. The court suspects you will find
the sensation expensive and addictive, in about equal measure."
Then the court turned, at last, to Las Palomas itself, and the temperature of the room changed the
way it changes before rain. Sheriff Harve Loomis was called, and stood, and was asked three
questions, and the three questions were the whole of him. Had he viewed the body of Samuel
Beckett before signing the inquest that certified a fall from a horse? He had not. Had he examined
the survey camp, the horse, the ground, or the widow, before certifying the manner of a death on
ground where a resurvey worth a valley's water was in dispute? He had not. Had he sworn the
warrant accusing Micah Trent of murder upon any evidence laid before him by any witness, or
upon instructions received from parties the court had that day heard named? Loomis looked, once,
at Silas Hollis, with an expression that had thirty years of trail partnership in it and found, at the
end of the thirty years, that the partnership had been a tenancy too. "I signed what was put in front
of me," he said, "in March and again this week, and I had got so used to signing what was put in
front of me that I had started calling the habit experience. The inquest was wrote out when it come
to me, Your Honour. So was the warrant. I will say who carried them to me when I am asked in a
place where my saying it is evidence and not conversation." "It will be asked," said Corwin. "In
Santa Fe, before a grand jury, where this court will send today's record entire. In the meantime,
Sheriff - you will surrender that star to the clerk of this court. Not in disgrace pronounced, for that
is another court's work, but because a man who has signed a murder into an accident and an
accident's witness into a murderer, without looking at either, has demonstrated, to this court's
complete satisfaction, that the star is heavier than his present strength. You will go home to Las
Palomas without it, sir, and explain the lightness to your county, which has been explaining you to
itself for some years and deserves the novelty." Loomis unpinned the star with hands that were not
steady, and laid it on the clerk's desk, and walked the length of the courtroom to the door a private
citizen for the first time in twenty years, and the room watched him go the way a town watches a
church being unbuilt: in silence, and with the feeling that the stones, at least, were innocent.
The findings, when Corwin delivered them in the late afternoon, with the light going the colour
of the brass cap on his table and the clerk writing as if the pen were hot, were read into the record
in the judge's own ploughshare hand, and they did, one by one, everything Hattie Beckett had
ridden sixty-two miles and crossed a flooded river to get written down in a book that travels with a
judge and sleeps in his valise. First: that the inquest of Las Palomas County upon the death of
Samuel Beckett, certifying a fall from a horse, was vacated, set aside, and struck, as founded upon
no examination and contradicted by the evidence, and that the record of the territory should show,
in its place, the true finding: that Samuel Beckett, territorial contract surveyor, was murdered on a
night in March 1883, at his survey camp on Alamito Creek, by a shot fired from the arroyo, after
refusing to certify a false corner, and that his death was staged by other hands to resemble the
accident the county afterwards certified. Sam's shirt was entered as an exhibit at that point,
unfolded once in public - the small, dark, pencil-point work above the left shoulder blade that
moths have never once been known to manage - and folded again, squared, by Hattie's own hands,
while the court waited. Her husband's name, the judge said, was cleared of the accident, of the fall,
of every implication of carelessness or drink or failure of horsemanship that a cheap inquest deals
out to a man who cannot answer it: the record would show a surveyor murdered at his work for
refusing to falsify it, which is the whole of the epitaph the man had earned, and the court directed
that a certified copy be furnished to his widow, at the territory's expense, since the territory had
furnished the original at hers.
Second: that the warrant out of Las Palomas charging Micah Trent with that murder was