good men, unremarkable and unharmed.
In the front room, where no patient had ever been received, Wade Tillery sat up all night in
Whitcomb's second-best chair with his boots off and his revolver on his knee, keeping the court's
watch over the court's witness, and if he slept, he did it the way guilty men sleep in other men's
houses, which is to say with his hat over his face and his conscience doing sentry duty in relays.
Once, near two o'clock, Hattie found him awake and looking at nothing, and he said, without
preamble, as men do at two o'clock, "In the morning, madam, they will have a doctor to say you are
mad, a lawyer to say your husband's papers are theirs, and a sheriff to say your witness is a
murderer. It is a considerable programme for a Wednesday." "It is the first of November, Deputy,"
Hattie said. "All Saints' Day. I have always thought it a good day to ask people to be accurate." He
considered this. "I have been accurate so seldom," he said, "that I am not sure the court will know
me." "The court," said Hattie, "will know you by your star. Straighten it before you are sworn, not
after. A man should put his house in order before he testifies, not during." She left him to it, and
heard, a moment later, the small, deliberate click of a star being set true against cloth, which in that
silent house sounded remarkably like a latch going home.
She spent the last dark hour at Whitcomb's kitchen table with the day-book open and everything
she owned in the world that mattered laid out in the order in which a judge, who was seventy and
deaf in one ear and had hanged men on less metal than this, might be expected to ask for it. The
field-book leaves. The duplicate plat, in Sam's hand, the true corners inked the way Sam inked a
thing he meant to be read after his death, though he had not known he was meaning it. Her
affidavit, three nights of it, and beside it, still sealed, still addressed in her own hand to a name
from an Ohio schoolroom, the parcel Whitcomb had kept since September and surrendered that
noon with the air of a man returning a borrowed umbrella at the end of a drought. She did not open
it: its whole value, until a court opened it, was that no living soul had. In the back cover of the daybook, in the slit she had cut for a pencil in another life, lay the last and smallest of her preparations,
which she had taken out of the sewing tin on the morning she left Alamito and carried sixty-two
miles without once letting herself think about it whole: a small rowel of blued steel, eight-pointed,
one point notched deep, in the way a man notches a thing he uses to count with. She had found it in
April, pressed into a crack in the stone beyond Sam's fire ring, where a horse had stood and
stamped in the night. She laid it now on the table in a twist of paper, next to the compass, next to
the cap that was not on the table because the cap was already lodged in a docket book that slept in a
judge's valise, and she looked at the row of them, the leavings of a marriage and a murder, and
thought that evidence, seen at four in the morning by lamplight, looked less like justice than like
the contents of a drawer emptied by a woman who had finally decided which things she was
keeping.
"Eat," Whitcomb said from the doorway, in his dressing gown, with the authority of a man who
has buried more patients than any lawyer in the territory has clients. "A court can smell a witness
who has not eaten, Mrs. Beckett, and it draws conclusions no objection can reach." She ate. It was a
morning for doing what she was told by the two or three people alive whose telling she had
decided, over a long summer, to accept.
The morning stage from Las Palomas had come in during the night, in the dark, with the
discretion of a travelling company that does not wish its scenery inspected, but Socorro at nine
o'clock in the morning is a place where discretion goes to die of exposure, and by eight the whole
town knew the cast. Silas Hollis got down from the stage in a black coat and a hat that had cost
more than Micah Trent's life had lately been valued at, and stood a moment in the plaza dust taking
the measure of Socorro the way a man takes the measure of a horse he intends to buy out from
under its rider: thoroughly, and without affection. He was fifty-eight, silver at the temples, built like
a courthouse. Vernon Pike followed him down, neat, grey, precise, folding his gloves finger by
finger, a ledger of a man, with the bank's counsel at his elbow: one Aldous Crane, of Santa Fe,
young enough to be brilliant and old enough to have sold the brilliance wholesale, whose boots
shone and whose briefcase had the swollen, satisfied look of a snake that has eaten recently and
expects to again. Their doctor came last, and Hattie, watching from Whitcomb's gallery with the