Biscuit met me at the door as if I had been gone for a week, tail going, nose working overtime on my coat, checking where I had been and whether I had brought anything edible back with me. I sat on the kitchen floor with him for a while, which is not a dignified place for a fifty-two-year-old man to sit, but it is where Biscuit likes to be comforted, and on that day I needed it as much as he did. I told him, out loud, that we had not done anything wrong, which sounded less convincing out loud than it had in my head. He leaned his grey muzzle against my knee and sighed, the deep, whole-body sigh of a beagle who has decided that whatever is happening, it is happening near a radiator and a person, and that is enough for now.
Lena came round just before four. She did not knock in her usual brisk way. She tapped, twice, lightly, and when I opened the door she was standing on the step with her coat still on and her hands in her pockets, as if she had come straight from the hall and had not yet decided whether staying was a good idea. She came in, refused tea, which Lena never does, and then sat at the kitchen table and looked at Biscuit, who had gone to sleep with his head on my foot, before she said what she had come to say.
She said she had seen Helen reposition the phone before she spoke. Not during, before. Lena had been watching because Helen had been fiddling with something in her pocket for a minute or two before she stood up, and Lena had assumed it was her keys. Then Helen had stood, and she had held the phone low and turned it slightly, twice, as if she were checking the angle, and only then had she started talking about the gate. Lena said it quietly, without drama, and she said she did not want to get involved, which is what people say right before they get involved because they cannot watch something unfair happen and say nothing. She said she was telling me because she thought I should know that it had not been spontaneous. Helen had not simply picked up her phone in the middle of a conversation. She had set it up first, and then she had spoken as if she were speaking to an audience that was not in the room.
I thanked her. I meant it. I also felt a cold, sinking feeling that I recognised from the past few weeks, the feeling of a small piece of information clicking into a shape I had been trying not to see. Lena stayed for a few minutes more, talking about ordinary things, the hall roof, the pothole, as if she were trying to put the morning back into its normal shape by talking about normal things. When she left, she squeezed my arm at the door and said, very quietly, that she did not think I was selfish, and that most people in the room probably did not either, they had just been caught off guard. I nodded, because I wanted to believe her, and because I was grateful, but I was not sure. Caught off guard is still caught, and a story told confidently in a room full of people has a way of sticking, even when the people in the room know, in some quieter corner of themselves, that it was not quite fair.
Mr. Okafor arrived later, after dark, with a small container of stew he insisted I take, on the grounds that I looked as if I had not eaten properly, which was true. He did not come in for long. He stood in the hallway with his coat on, Biscuit sniffing hopefully at the container, and he told me something that made the cold feeling settle deeper. He said Helen had used the same line earlier that week, word for word, or near enough that he had noticed. He had been at the bus stop on Wednesday, he said, waiting for the bus that was late, as usual, and Helen had been talking to two other neighbours there, and she had said, in almost exactly the same tone, that a shared gate was a shared responsibility, and that keeping it locked was putting one person's convenience ahead of everyone else's ease. He had not thought much of it at the time. It had sounded like a general comment, the kind of thing people say at bus stops. Hearing it again in the hall, delivered as if it had just occurred to her, he had realised she had rehearsed it. He said the word rehearsed without emphasis, as if he were simply describing what he had heard, and then he shrugged, a small, uncomfortable shrug, and said he did not like to think badly of anyone, but he did not like to be used as an audience either.