And yet the small pushes kept accumulating in my mind, not because any one of them was serious, but because they all pointed in the same direction. A pointed comment at the fence, made to sound like an observation. A leaf-blower at dawn, aimed toward my windows, on a morning when there were hardly any leaves to blow. A bin moved to block the path to the gate I kept locked. Each time, I had stayed calm. Each time, I had not shouted, not complained in any formal way, not knocked on her door to demand an explanation. I had swept, I had moved the bin back, I had made tea. I had behaved, I thought, exactly as a reasonable neighbour should behave when faced with unreasonable smallness. I had not given Helen a row. I had not given her a scene. I had not given her anything she could repeat to someone else as evidence that I was difficult.
What I had not expected, and what I only began to understand in that week, was that calm might not be the end of the matter. It might be the beginning of something else. Because on the morning after the bin conversation, I happened to glance out of my back window while Helen was in her garden, and I caught her looking toward my house, not gardening, not waving, just looking, with an expression I had not seen on her face before. She was not angry. She was not triumphant. She looked, for a moment, almost disappointed, as if she had been expecting something from me and I had failed to provide it. She looked like someone who had set a small test and found that the result was not the one she had hoped for. When she saw me looking, she smiled quickly, a bright, tidy smile that did not quite reach the rest of her face, and turned back to her roses. I stood at the window with Biscuit leaning against my leg, and I felt a small, cold shift in my understanding of my neighbour. I had thought the pushes were about the gate. I was beginning to wonder whether the gate was only the excuse, and the reaction was the real prize.
That look stayed with me longer than the leaf-blower had. It was not anger, exactly, and it was not the tight, satisfied smile of someone who had won a point. It was flatter than that, a kind of letdown, as if she had set a table for a quarrel and I had failed to sit down at it. I kept turning it over while I washed Biscuit's bowl that evening and while I tried to settle back into a map I was inking for a walking-guide client, a fiddly parish boundary that needed steady hands. My hands were steady enough. My mind was not. I told myself I was reading too much into a face glimpsed across a fence in bad morning light. Helen Voss and I had disagreed about a gate, nothing more. She wanted it open. I wanted it shut. People disagreed about gates all the time in Alderbrook without it becoming a story. And yet I could not shake the sense that my calm had disappointed her, and that a person who is disappointed by calm might try again, a little harder, to find the edge of it.
Biscuit, for his part, had already forgotten the morning. He was twelve, or close to it, a senior beagle with a grey muzzle and a stiff back leg that made him hop rather than run when he got excited, which was still often, usually about toast crusts. He slept under my desk while I worked, snoring in short, polite bursts, and every hour or so he would lift his head, look at me as if to check I was still there, and settle again. The gate mattered to him in a practical way only. If it was shut, the garden was his. If it was open, the lane was suddenly interesting, and interesting, for a beagle, meant nose first through a gap and trouble second. That was why I locked it. It was not a principle I had carved into stone. It was a latch, a key I kept on a hook by the back door, and a habit I had formed after two night cut-throughs in the spring when strangers had used our alley to get to the bus stop road and one of them had left the gate swinging wide at two in the morning. I had found Biscuit standing in the lane in his confusion, blinking at the dark, and I had decided then that I would rather be thought unfriendly than lose him to a bus.