Then I opened the folder. I laid out my journal first, and I explained what it was: a dated record I had started keeping when the disagreement stopped being a single conversation and started becoming a series of small incidents, each one easy to dismiss on its own and harder to ignore together. I read out the dates and the brief entries, not the feelings attached to them, and I tried to keep to facts. I mentioned the morning I found the gate propped open with a stone after I had locked it the night before, and the evening I found it open again, and the times I had re-locked it and found fresh marks on the latch where it had been forced rather than simply unlatched. I mentioned the notes left on my gate, the first polite, the later ones less so, and I said I had kept copies and photographs of each one. I did not read the later notes aloud in full. I said only that their tone had changed over time, and that one of them had crossed a line for me, because it had mentioned my late father in a way that had nothing to do with a gate. Ms. Adeyemi asked me, gently, whether I had that note with me, and I said I did, in an envelope, and that I had photographed it on the day I found it so there would be a record even if the paper itself were lost. She asked if I was willing for her to see it privately, rather than having it read aloud to the whole room, and I said yes, that was what I preferred. I slid the envelope across the table to her, and she opened it just enough to read it herself, her expression changing very slightly, and then she sealed it again and placed it to one side, face down. She did not quote it, and she did not ask me to quote it, and I was grateful for that restraint, because I did not want my father's name turned into a debating point in a hall full of people who had never met him.
I went on to the photographs. I showed the picture of the gate latch, the picture of the stone that had been used to prop the gate, and the picture of the chalk marks that had appeared on my side of the alley wall one morning, marks that meant nothing on their own but that, in context, had felt like another small pressure. I said that plainly, because it was true, and because I thought Ms. Adeyemi would understand the difference between documenting something for yourself and filming someone to use against them later. I also said, and I meant it, that I was not claiming Helen had done every single thing in the journal. Some of the night cut-throughs could have been strangers. Some of the litter could have blown in from the lane. I was not there for every incident, and I did not want to overstate what I knew. What I was saying was that the pattern, taken together, had made me feel watched and worn down in my own home, and that the lock, for me, was not about winning an argument about a gate but about being able to sleep without listening for footsteps and to let Biscuit out without standing at the back door worrying about where he might wander. When I finished, my hands were shaking slightly, and I folded them on top of the folder to hide it. Ms. Adeyemi thanked me, and said she appreciated the care I had taken to distinguish what I had seen from what I had assumed, and that distinction, she said, would matter in what followed.
She turned then to Mr. Okafor, and asked him to speak about what he had personally seen, rather than what he had heard from either of us. Mr. Okafor cleared his throat and spoke slowly, in the measured way he always spoke, as if he were choosing each word to be sure it was accurate. He said he lived across the alley and could see both gardens from his kitchen window, and that he had noticed the gate standing open on several mornings after he had seen me lock it the evening before. He said he had also noticed, on more than one occasion, Helen standing near the gate with her phone in her hand, repositioning it, holding it up and then lowering it again, as if she were framing a shot, and that on one of those occasions she had waited until I was on a work call in the garden, speaking loudly to a client about a deadline, before she called out to me about the gate. He also spoke about the bicycle incident, which I had written about in my journal but had not dwelt on in my own account: he had seen a bicycle left leaning across the alley entrance one afternoon, blocking the path, and he had seen Helen move it only after I had come out and asked, politely, if it could be shifted so Biscuit could pass. He said he had not seen who had placed the bicycle there, and he would not claim that he had, but he had seen that it was there and that it had not been moved until I spoke. His account was short, and he apologised for its shortness, but Ms. Adeyemi told him that short and precise was exactly what she needed, and she wrote down his words as he spoke them, checking back with him once to make sure she had the sequence right.