The association hall smelled of old wood polish and tea that had been left too long in a pot, and the late morning light coming through the high windows fell in flat rectangles across the long table where we were supposed to sit and be reasonable with each other. I arrived twenty minutes early because I did not want to be the man who walked in late to a meeting about his own temper, and I sat for a while in my car with Biscuit asleep on the back seat, his head on his paws, breathing in that slow, snoring way he has when he is truly settled. I had left the folder on the passenger seat beside me, a plain blue folder with nothing written on the front, and inside it were the things I had gathered over the past weeks: my journal, printed in my own handwriting and then typed up so it would be legible; the photographs I had taken on my phone and printed at the library, each one with the date written in pencil on the back; and the note, folded once and sealed in a plain white envelope, which I had not opened again since the day I found it tucked under my gate latch. I did not intend to wave it around. I intended to keep it closed unless I had to show that I had it, and even then I intended to let Ms. Adeyemi decide how much of it needed to be said aloud. That felt important to me. I did not want the meeting to become about a single cruel sentence. I wanted it to be about a pattern, about weeks of small pressures building into something that could no longer be lived next to quietly.
When I went inside, Ms. Adeyemi was already there, arranging chairs around the table rather than in rows, so that no one would be facing an audience. She was a calm, precise woman in her fifties, with a notebook open in front of her and a pen laid exactly parallel to its edge, and she greeted me by name without any particular warmth or coldness, which I found reassuring. She asked me to sit on one side of the table and told me Helen would sit on the other, with Mr. Okafor and Lena in the chairs at the ends, so that everyone could see everyone else and no one would have to turn around to speak. She explained, in the same even tone, that she was not a judge and that this was not a court, that her job was to listen, to ask questions, and to recommend a way forward that both households could live with, and that she would write down whatever was agreed so there would be no argument later about what had been said. She asked if I understood, and I said I did. She asked if I had brought anything I wanted her to see, and I told her I had a folder, but that I would rather wait until it was my turn to speak. She nodded as if that were exactly the right answer, and wrote something in her notebook that I could not read from where I sat.
Helen arrived five minutes before the scheduled start, carrying a handbag and a phone and a small stack of papers of her own, and she did not look at me as she came in. She sat down, placed her phone face up on the table in front of her, and folded her hands over her papers. Mr. Okafor came in next, nodding to both of us, and Lena after him, looking a little nervous but determined, the way someone looks when they have decided to tell the truth even though they would rather not be involved at all. Ms. Adeyemi waited until the door was closed and the hall was quiet, and then she began by stating the purpose of the meeting in plain language: there was a disagreement about the shared alley gate between 12 and 14 Willowmere Lane, about whether it should be kept locked or left open, and about conduct between neighbours that had made the disagreement harder to live with. She asked us both to keep our voices down, to speak about what we had seen and done rather than about what we believed the other person intended, and to leave the hall with an agreement if we could. Helen nodded quickly, as if she were already agreeing with a decision in her favour, and I nodded too, because I wanted an agreement, even if it was not the one she wanted.