Biscuit barked, of course. He was a beagle, and he was old, and he barked at the postman and at cats on the fence and sometimes at nothing at all that I could see, just a smell on the wind that excited him. But he did not bark for long periods in the evening. In the evening he was usually asleep on his blanket by the fire, or pressed against my leg on the sofa, snoring softly. I knew that because I was there. I had also started keeping a journal weeks earlier, after the first real trouble over the gate, and in that journal I had been writing down, in plain lines, what actually happened each day: when Biscuit barked, for how long, what set him off, when the gate was opened or closed, who came through the alley, what Helen said. It was not a diary in the emotional sense. It was dates and times and short facts, because I had learned, the hard way, that memory blurs when you are upset, and facts do not.
That journal was the reason I did not panic outright when I read the association letter. I put it down on the table, made tea, let Biscuit out into the garden, and stood at the back window watching him sniff his way around the flower beds while I tried to think clearly. The gate was shut, as it always was now unless I was taking him out. The latch clicked when I had closed it that morning. Beyond it, the alley ran down to the lane, and beyond the lane was the road to the bus stop, and I could see Helen's back window from where I stood, the curtain half drawn, and I wondered if she was watching me back. I did not look for long. I finished my tea, brought Biscuit in, and went upstairs to get the journal.
It was a plain notebook with a dark blue cover, the kind you can buy in any stationery shop, and the pages were filling up faster than I had expected. I turned to the most recent entries and checked them against the three complaints. For noise, I had nothing to check, because there had been nothing to write down. On the days Helen said I was noisy, according to the dates in the association letter, I had been out, or I had been drawing in silence, or Ruth had called and we had talked for twenty minutes in normal voices. For Biscuit, I had entries like "6:12 p.m., Biscuit barked twice at cat on fence, stopped when called," and "8:40 p.m., one short bark at doorbell, settled at once." Nothing like hours of barking. Nothing that kept anyone awake, unless they were listening very hard for a reason to be kept awake.
For the gate as a fire risk, I had my own notes too. I had checked, months earlier, when the disagreement first started, that both houses had their own front exits and their own side access, and that the alley gate was not anyone's only way out. Helen's garden had a side path to her own front drive. Mine had the same on my side. The gate was a convenience for cutting through to the bus stop, not an escape route, and locking it did not trap anyone in either garden. I had written that down at the time, with the date I had walked both paths myself to be sure, because I did not want to be the kind of neighbour who insisted on something without checking first.
I sat with the notebook for a long time that morning, and I felt something shift in me. Up until then, most of the trouble had been face to face: words at the fence, a sharp comment at a coffee morning, a look across the garden. This was different. This was paper. This was a formal complaint, filed in writing, with my name on it, and it would sit in a file somewhere even if nothing came of it. It felt heavier than an argument, and also, strangely, more manageable, because paper could be answered with paper, and I had paper of my own.
I decided, right there, that I would answer calmly and in writing, with dates, and that I would not write anything I could not back up. I would not call Helen names. I would not guess at her motives in the letter. I would just set out what had happened, day by day, and let the facts do the work. It took me most of that Tuesday to draft it. I wrote it by hand first, then typed it, then read it aloud to Biscuit, who listened with his head on his paws and looked unimpressed, which was probably fair. I kept the sentences short. I said that I worked from home as a freelance map illustrator, that my work involved no loud equipment, and that I was happy for anyone to confirm that. I said that Biscuit was a senior beagle who barked briefly at ordinary triggers and settled quickly, and I gave examples with dates and times from my journal. I said that the gate was kept locked for Biscuit's safety and to stop night cut-throughs through our gardens, that both properties had independent front access, and that I had checked that myself. I ended by saying I wanted a fair outcome and was willing to attend mediation, which I already knew was scheduled, and I signed it and dated it and put a copy in my folder.