Ms. Adeyemi turned to Helen first, as she had said she would, and Helen began at once, without hesitation, in the confident voice of someone used to chairing meetings and being listened to. She said she had lived at number 12 for many years, that she had always used the alley gate as a shortcut to the lane and the bus stop, and that the gate had always been open in the past, or at least left on the latch, so that anyone in the street could pass through without thinking about it. She said that since I had moved in and begun locking it, she had felt shut out of her own neighbourhood, that she had to walk the long way around the block to reach the bus, and that on wet mornings the longer route left her shoes soaked and her coat damp before her day had even begun. She said the locked gate was a danger, because if there were a fire or a medical emergency in either garden, a locked gate would slow help down, and she said she worried about that every night. Her voice rose slightly when she said that, and she looked directly at Ms. Adeyemi, not at me, as if I were not really present at all. Then she said the moment I had been expecting, the moment she had been building toward in her complaints: that I was aggressive, that I had shouted at her in the garden, that I had confronted her at the coffee morning, and that she no longer felt safe walking past my house. She said she had evidence, and she picked up her phone.
The clip she played was short, less than a minute long, and I recognised it immediately. It was from the coffee morning, from the moment when I had asked her, firmly but without shouting, to stop filming me while I was talking to Lena about Biscuit. In the clip, my voice sounded louder than I remembered it sounding, because the phone had been held close and the hall that day had been noisy, and my face, caught at an angle, looked tense. What the clip did not show was the minute before it, when Helen had stepped directly into my conversation, raised her own voice to say that I was frightening people, and lifted her phone only after Lena had turned away. What it did not show was the minute after it, when I had stepped back, put my hands in my pockets, and walked to the tea table to pour myself a cup I did not want, simply to give everyone some space. The clip ended abruptly, mid-sentence, on a frame where my mouth was open, and Helen set the phone down with a small, satisfied movement, as if the picture had settled the matter. She said that was the kind of behaviour she had been dealing with, that she did not feel she should have to explain herself to a neighbour who spoke to her like that, and that the gate should be left permanently open so that the street could return to normal. She folded her arms and waited, and for a moment the hall was completely silent except for the ticking of the clock on the wall.
Ms. Adeyemi thanked Helen, wrote something down, and then turned to me and asked me to speak in my own time. I took a slow breath before I began, because I could feel my heart beating faster than I wanted it to, and I did not want the first thing I said in that room to sound defensive. I said my name, my address, and that I worked from home as a freelance map illustrator, which meant I was in the house for most of the day, and that Biscuit, my senior beagle, spent time in the back garden when the weather allowed. I said I had begun locking the shared alley gate for two reasons, and that both of them were practical rather than personal. The first was Biscuit's safety: he was old, his hearing was not what it had been, and if the gate stood open he could wander out into the lane and toward the road before I noticed he was gone. The second was that the alley had begun to be used at night by people cutting through from the lane to the main road, people who did not live in our street, and I had found litter in the alley in the morning and heard footsteps past my bedroom window after midnight more than once. I kept my voice level as I said that, and I looked at Ms. Adeyemi rather than at Helen, because I wanted to be heard rather than to win an argument with my eyes.