The Woman Next Door Kept Pushing Me to Fight Back — She Never Realized I Knew Exactly What She Wanted

Chapter 34

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Lena spoke next, and she was more nervous than Mr. Okafor, twisting a tissue in her hands as she talked, but her account was clear. She said she had been at the coffee morning and had been standing near me when Helen had begun filming, and that what she remembered most was not my raised voice but the way Helen had moved her phone, stepping sideways to get a better angle, and then stepping back as if she were not filming at all when other people looked over. Lena said she had felt uncomfortable at the time, because it had not felt like someone recording a memory; it had felt like someone collecting a moment to show later, cut off from everything around it. She also spoke about the chalk incident, saying she had walked past the alley one morning and had seen fresh chalk marks on the wall on my side, and that later that same day she had seen Helen in the alley with a piece of chalk in her hand, though she could not say for certain that Helen had made those particular marks, and she was careful to say so. Ms. Adeyemi nodded at that carefulness, and asked Lena one follow-up question about the coffee morning: whether I had shouted, in her hearing, or whether I had spoken firmly. Lena thought for a moment and said firmly, not shouting, and that she had heard shouting in that hall on other occasions and knew the difference. She added, almost as an afterthought, that after the filming, I had walked away rather than continuing the argument, and that she had noticed that because she had expected the argument to continue and it had not. When she finished, she looked relieved, as if a weight had lifted, and Ms. Adeyemi thanked her for coming, especially since it could not have been easy to speak about a neighbour in a room with that neighbour present.

Ms. Adeyemi then asked if my sister Ruth could be reached by phone, since Ruth had been mentioned in my written response as someone I had spoken to during the disagreement, and I said yes, Ruth was waiting for a call if she was needed, but that she had not been present for any of the incidents and could only speak about what I had told her at the time. Ms. Adeyemi considered that for a moment, and then said she would not need to call Ruth, because what mattered for her decision was what had been seen first-hand in the alley and the hall, and Ruth's account would necessarily be second-hand. I was relieved, in a way, because I had not wanted to drag Ruth into a meeting she had not asked to join, and because I knew that anything she said would simply be a repetition of my own words, which Ms. Adeyemi already had. Ms. Adeyemi then turned back to Helen and asked her a series of measured questions, each one delivered without any edge in her voice, as if she were simply trying to fill gaps in a picture. She asked Helen whether she had propped the gate open, and Helen said she had, on occasion, because she believed the gate should be open and because she did not accept that one neighbour could decide for the whole street. She asked Helen whether she had filmed at the coffee morning, and Helen said she had, because she wanted a record of how she was spoken to, and she did not see why that should be held against her. She asked Helen about the timing of her approaches to me, about whether she had chosen moments when I was on work calls, and Helen dismissed that as coincidence, saying she had no way of knowing when I was working and that I worked from home all day, so any time would be a work time. She asked Helen about the note, without quoting it, and Helen's face tightened. She said she had written notes to me about the gate, that she stood by what she had written about the gate, and that she did not remember the exact wording of every note. Ms. Adeyemi did not press her further on that point in front of everyone, but she made a note in her book, and I saw her underline something twice, slowly, as if she wanted to be sure she would return to it.

News in the same category

The Woman Next Door Kept Pushing Me to Fight Back — She Never Realized I Knew Exactly What She Wanted

45 Part