They Cut the Judge's Braids in Her Own Courthouse — Then All Rise Echoed Through the Trial That Followed Them

Chapter 17

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Angela Foster's partial recording proved to be more useful than anyone had expected. She had been at her desk, and when she heard raised voices at the staff entrance, she had taken out her phone, not to make a scene, but because she had a feeling, the kind of feeling that comes from twelve years of watching a courthouse, that what was happening might matter later. The recording was only ninety seconds long, shaky, the sound muffled by distance, but it showed Captain Royce Tanner holding Celeste Warren's identification up, showed Officer Kyle Preston reaching for her arm, showed Celeste Warren standing very still, her hands visible, her voice calm, saying, "I am Judge Celeste Warren. My identification is valid. Please check it with the clerk's office." The recording did not show the private room. It did not show the clippers. But it showed the beginning, and the beginning mattered, because it showed a woman who was not resisting, not shouting, not threatening, but asking, politely, for a simple check that would have resolved the matter in a minute. Samuel Grant watched Angela Foster's recording three times, and then he called her in for an interview, and she told him, in her own words, what she had seen and heard, and why she had pressed record, and he thanked her for her courage, because it took courage to press record when the people you are recording are the people who control the building you work in.

Maya Thompson, twenty-two, the law-student intern whom Celeste Warren mentored, was also interviewed, not because she had been present that morning, but because she had been in the building the week before, and Samuel Grant was building a picture of the courthouse, of how screening usually worked, of whether what had happened to Celeste Warren was an isolated failure or part of a pattern. Maya Thompson told him that Celeste Warren had taught her, in their mentoring sessions, to watch how a courthouse treated the people who had the least power in it, because that was where you learned what an institution truly believed. She said that she had seen officers be courteous to judges and lawyers, and brusque to members of the public, and that she had noticed, without quite knowing what to do with the observation, that the brusqueness seemed to fall more heavily on Black visitors, on older visitors, on visitors who did not look like they belonged. She did not claim that she had seen discrimination. She said only what she had seen, and Samuel Grant wrote it down, because a pattern is built from many small observations, and hers was one of them.

Captain Royce Tanner was interviewed on the third day of the investigation, in a conference room with his union representative present, as was his right, and with Samuel Grant asking the questions in a tone that was firm but not hostile. Tanner, forty-seven, head of courthouse security, a man who had built his career on being decisive, on making quick judgments under pressure, sat upright in his chair, his hands folded on the table, and gave his account without hesitation. He said that Celeste Warren's identification had looked unfamiliar to him, that the photograph did not match his expectation, that he had believed, in good faith, that it might be false, and that he had acted to secure the building. He said that the handcuffs had been standard procedure for a person being detained for further questioning, that the private room had been chosen to protect her privacy, and that the cutting of her braids had been a security check, to ensure that nothing was concealed in her hair, a check he said he had seen done before, though when Samuel Grant asked him to name a previous instance, or to point to a written procedure authorizing it, Tanner paused, and then said he could not recall a specific instance, and that the procedure was a matter of officer discretion.

Samuel Grant listened without interrupting, and then he asked, quietly, a series of questions that were not accusations but were not easy either. If the identification looked false, why had no one called the clerk's office, which was twenty feet away, to verify it? If the concern was security, why had the officers not simply escorted Celeste Warren to Chief Judge Patricia Cole's chambers, where her identity could have been confirmed in a minute? If the hair check was standard, why was there no written procedure for it, no record of it being done to anyone else, no consent form, no supervisor's approval sought in advance? And why, Samuel Grant asked, looking down at his notes, did the incident report Tanner had filed that same morning mention a security check but not mention handcuffs, and not mention the cutting of hair at all? Tanner's answers grew shorter as the questions went on. He said he had been under pressure. He said he had made a judgment call. He said he had not intended any disrespect. He said, several times, that he had been doing his job. Samuel Grant wrote down each answer exactly as it was given, and when the interview ended, he thanked Tanner for his time, and told him, as he told everyone, that he would be given an opportunity to review his statement and to add anything he wished to add, because fairness required that, too.

News in the same category

They Cut the Judge's Braids in Her Own Courthouse — Then All Rise Echoed Through the Trial That Followed Them

45 Part