They Cut the Judge's Braids in Her Own Courthouse — Then All Rise Echoed Through the Trial That Followed Them

Chapter 9

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Celeste listened, as she always listened, with her pen in her hand, taking notes, asking questions when clarification was needed, watching the witness's face, watching the lawyers' faces, watching the room. She asked Denise about dates, about times, about the names of officers, about whether she had kept records, about whether she had complained, and Denise answered each question directly, without exaggeration, without anger, with the calm of a person who had waited a long time to be heard and who was determined to use her time well.

As Denise testified, Celeste thought about the morning, about the staff entrance, about Preston and Barrett and Tanner, about the small grey room and the clippers and the braids on the floor, and she felt a deep, quiet recognition: that what Denise was describing, and what she herself had experienced, were not separate stories. They were the same story, told from different positions, one by a visitor and one by a judge, and the fact that it had happened to a judge, in her own courthouse, on a morning when she was scheduled to hear a case about exactly this issue, was not a coincidence to be ignored. It was a fact to be noted, carefully, and to be addressed through the proper channels, with fairness and with process, not with anger and not with haste.

The hearing continued through the morning, witness after witness, each one describing a similar experience, each one answering Celeste's questions with care. Marcus Bell was methodical, building his case piece by piece, and the defence lawyers were thorough, challenging dates, questioning memories, pointing to the written policy, arguing that the screening was neutral and that any differences were the result of individual circumstances. Celeste listened to both sides, she weighed their arguments, she asked questions of her own, and she kept the proceedings moving with the steady hand she had always brought to her courtroom.

At noon, she called a recess, and she returned to her chambers, where Jordan was waiting with a sandwich she did not eat and a glass of water she drank slowly, and where her phone buzzed with a message from David, asking if she was all right, and a message from Naomi, asking about the hearing, and a message from her friend Dr. Evelyn Brooks, fifty-seven, a physician who had known Celeste since college, asking if she wanted to talk. Celeste answered each message briefly, telling David she was safe and would call him later, telling Naomi the hearing was going well, telling Evelyn she would call that evening. She did not tell any of them what had happened at the staff entrance, not yet, because she needed time to think about how to tell it, and to whom, and in what order, and because she knew that once she told it, it would become a story that other people would carry, and she wanted to be sure, first, that she had the facts straight in her own mind.

In the afternoon, the hearing resumed, and more witnesses testified, and the defence called its own witnesses, including Frank Delgado, fifty-eight, the Director of Court Security, who testified about the written policy, about the training officers received, about the procedures for verifying identification, and about the importance of security in a federal courthouse. Celeste listened to him carefully, and she asked him questions about the policy, about how it was applied in practice, about what happened when an officer doubted a person's identification, about what records were kept, about what oversight existed. Delgado answered in a formal, measured tone, and Celeste noted his answers, and she noted the places where his answers were precise and the places where they were vague, and she kept her own counsel, as a judge must, until the time came to decide.

By four o'clock, the hearing was drawing to a close, and Celeste thanked the parties for their preparation, and she told them she would take the matter under advisement and issue a written order in due course. She reminded them that the court expected all parties to behave with civility toward one another while the matter was pending, and she adjourned the hearing. The room rose as she left the bench, and she walked back to her chambers, and she closed the door behind her, and she sat at her desk, and she took off her robe, and she hung it on its hook, and she sat for a long moment, looking out the window at the late afternoon light falling across Courthouse Square.

News in the same category

They Cut the Judge's Braids in Her Own Courthouse — Then All Rise Echoed Through the Trial That Followed Them

45 Part