They Cut the Judge's Braids in Her Own Courthouse — Then All Rise Echoed Through the Trial That Followed Them

Chapter 26

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Celeste asked Maya Thompson what she had noticed about Denise's testimony, and Maya Thompson said she had noticed that Denise had not exaggerated, and that she had been willing to say when she did not remember something, and that this made her more believable, not less. Celeste nodded and said that was exactly right, and that a witness who admitted uncertainty was often more credible than a witness who claimed perfect recall, because memory was human and honest witnesses knew its limits. She asked Maya Thompson what she had noticed about the cross-examination, and Maya Thompson said she had noticed that the questions had tried to make Denise doubt herself, not by accusing her of lying, but by suggesting that she might have misunderstood, and Celeste said that was a common technique, and that the best answer to it was the one Denise had given, which was to stay calm, to answer only what was asked, and to return, gently, to what she knew to be true.

They walked together to a small conference room where Jordan Ellis was waiting with a stack of files, and Celeste spent the next hour with Maya Thompson going through the hearing binder, explaining how the exhibits were organized, how the timeline had been constructed from the security logs and the complaint records, and how the panel would weigh testimony against documents. She showed Maya Thompson the written screening policy as it existed, which was brief and vague, and she showed her the draft proposals for a clearer policy that Marcus Bell had prepared, and she asked Maya Thompson to read both and tell her what was missing. Maya Thompson read carefully and said that the existing policy did not say what an officer should do when a visitor wore a religious head covering, or braids, or a medical device, or when a visitor asked for a private screening, and Celeste said that was precisely the gap, and that a policy that did not address those situations left too much to individual discretion.

Celeste asked Maya Thompson to draft a short memorandum, no more than two pages, summarizing the gaps she had found and suggesting language that would close them, and Maya Thompson's eyes widened slightly, because she had not expected to be given that responsibility so soon. Celeste told her that she trusted her judgment, and that she would review the draft with her line by line, and that making a mistake in a draft was part of learning, while making a mistake in a final filing was something they would avoid by reviewing together. Maya Thompson thanked her and set to work, and Celeste sat beside her, not hovering, but available, answering questions when Maya Thompson asked them and otherwise letting her think.

While Maya Thompson worked, Celeste thought about her own braids, which she had worn since law school and which were now growing back slowly after the clippers in the security room. She thought about how much they meant to her, not as a fashion choice, but as a part of her identity, a connection to her mother and grandmother, a reminder of who she was when she put on the robe and took the bench. She thought about the way she had felt when they were cut, not only the shock, but the sense that something personal had been taken without permission, and she thought about how Denise Carter must have felt when her headwrap was removed in front of strangers. She did not dwell on anger, because anger would not help her do her work well, but she allowed herself to acknowledge the loss, and then she returned her attention to the files in front of her, because the hearing needed her focus and the people who had testified deserved a careful, fair process.

In the afternoon, Celeste met with Dr. Evelyn Brooks, her friend of many years, for coffee in the courthouse cafeteria, and Evelyn Brooks asked her how she was sleeping, and Celeste answered honestly that she was sleeping better than she had in the first weeks after the incident, but that she still woke sometimes in the night thinking about the sound of the clippers. Evelyn Brooks listened without offering easy reassurance, and she asked Celeste whether she had spoken to David Warren about it, and Celeste said she had, and that David Warren had been patient and steady, and that Naomi Warren had called every evening since the hearing began, and that their support had made a difference. Evelyn Brooks said that it was good to have people who would listen without trying to fix everything, and Celeste agreed, and they talked for a while about ordinary things, about Evelyn Brooks's work, about a book they had both been reading, about the garden David Warren was tending at home, and the ordinariness of the conversation was itself a kind of rest.

News in the same category

They Cut the Judge's Braids in Her Own Courthouse — Then All Rise Echoed Through the Trial That Followed Them

45 Part