They Cut the Judge's Braids in Her Own Courthouse — Then All Rise Echoed Through the Trial That Followed Them

Chapter 31

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The panel also found that the officers had not followed a consistent procedure, that the decision to take Celeste to a private security room had not been documented at the time, and that the cutting of her braids had not been authorized by any written policy or by a supervisor outside the room. The panel noted that Captain Royce Tanner had offered a justification based on security, but that the justification was not supported by the footage or by the testimony of other witnesses, and that Officer Kyle Preston's later doubts, expressed to Samuel Grant during the investigation, were consistent with the evidence. The panel noted that Officer Sean Barrett had remained silent during the investigation and the hearing, and that his silence, while his right, left the record incomplete on certain points, and the panel said it would consider that silence only in the context of the full record, not as a finding on its own.

The findings were not a final disciplinary decision, the presiding member explained, but a factual record on which the disciplinary process would proceed, and the officers would have a full opportunity to respond, to present evidence, and to be represented by counsel. The panel emphasized that the process would be fair, that no outcome had been predetermined, and that the goal was accountability and reform, not punishment for its own sake. Celeste listened to the findings with her hands folded, her expression calm, and when the reading was finished, she looked at Marcus Bell and nodded, as if to say that the record was now clear, and that whatever followed would follow from that record.

In the days that followed, the disciplinary process moved forward under the oversight of Chief Judge Patricia Cole and Director of Court Security Frank Delgado, who worked together to ensure that each step was documented and that each officer received notice of the specific allegations against him and an opportunity to respond. Samuel Grant provided his investigative report, including the security footage, the badge numbers and times Celeste had memorized, the clerk's partial recording, and the statements he had taken from the officers and other witnesses. Angela Foster provided the court records that confirmed Celeste's identity and her schedule on the morning of the incident, and U.S. Marshal Teresa Alvarez provided information about standard security procedures in other federal courthouses, to give the process a basis for comparison.

Captain Royce Tanner was the first to respond in the disciplinary process, submitting a written statement in which he maintained that he had acted out of concern for security, but acknowledged that the incident had not been handled well and that he regretted the distress it had caused. He requested a hearing, and when that hearing was held, he appeared with counsel and testified that he had believed, in the moment, that further checking was required, but that he now understood that his belief had not been supported by the facts, and that he should have verified Celeste's identification through the clerk's office rather than proceeding to a private room. He said he had served in courthouse security for many years and that he had always tried to protect the building and the people in it, and he said he was sorry for what had happened to Celeste Warren, and for the harm it had caused to trust in the courthouse.

His apology was sincere in its tone, but it had limits, and Celeste, listening from the gallery where she attended as an interested party but not as a decision-maker, recognized those limits clearly. Tanner apologized for the distress and for the handling of the incident, but he did not fully acknowledge that cutting her braids had been wrong in itself, rather than merely a mistake in procedure, and he did not acknowledge the pattern of uneven screening that Denise Carter and others had described. He spoke about security, and about his intentions, but he spoke less about the impact on Celeste and on the community, and he did not propose any changes to the way he would approach similar situations in the future. Marcus Bell, speaking after the hearing, said that an apology was a step, but that accountability required more than words, and that the disciplinary process would need to consider whether Tanner understood the full scope of what had happened and was prepared to change.

News in the same category

They Cut the Judge's Braids in Her Own Courthouse — Then All Rise Echoed Through the Trial That Followed Them

45 Part