They Cut the Judge's Braids in Her Own Courthouse — Then All Rise Echoed Through the Trial That Followed Them

Chapter 2

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

David poured water into two mugs and set one in front of her. "And you are the judge who has to decide whether the courthouse that employs her is doing it fairly."

"That is the job," Celeste said. "The law does not stop at the front door. If anything, it starts there."

They talked for a while about ordinary things, about the roof that needed a patch before winter, about Naomi, their daughter, who was in her second year of law school and had called the night before, excited and exhausted in equal measure, about a moot court brief she was writing. Naomi Warren was twenty-four, and she had her mother's steadiness and her father's curiosity, and Celeste felt, as she often did, a quiet pride that did not need to be spoken aloud. Naomi had grown up watching her mother braid her hair in the morning and put on a robe in the afternoon, and she had decided, without any pressure from either parent, that she wanted to learn the law from the inside, the way her mother had. Celeste had told her, more than once, that the law was slow and often disappointing, that it asked for patience more than brilliance, and Naomi had listened and then gone ahead anyway, which was, Celeste thought, exactly the right response.

At six-forty, Celeste rinsed her mug, set it in the dishwasher, and gathered her bag. Inside it were the briefs for the day's hearing, a legal pad, three pens, a bottle of water, and a small tin of mints she kept for long afternoons. She checked the weather on her phone. Rain had cleared. The sky would be pale and bright. She kissed David goodbye at the door, and he held her hand for a moment longer than usual, the way he sometimes did when he sensed that a day would ask more of her than most.

"Call me when it is done," he said.

"I will," she said.

The drive to the courthouse took twenty minutes when traffic was light, and this morning it was light. Magnolia Falls was a city of about ninety thousand people, set in the rolling hills of central Georgia, with a downtown that had been built in the nineteen-twenties and then rebuilt, piece by piece, over the decades. Celeste drove past the high school where David taught, past the library where she had studied as a girl, past the park where Naomi had learned to ride a bicycle. The streets were familiar in the way that only a hometown can be familiar, every corner holding a memory, every building holding a story. She had grown up here, she had left for college and law school, and she had come back, because she believed that a person could do the most good in the place that had made them.

She thought about the hearing as she drove, not in the frantic way of a person cramming, but in the slow, deliberate way she had trained herself to think. The case was called, in her mind, by the names of the people who had brought it, not by its docket number. The plaintiffs were three residents of Magnolia Falls who said they had been stopped, searched, and delayed at the courthouse entrance on multiple occasions, while white visitors had passed through with a nod. They were represented by Marcus Bell, a civil-rights attorney of forty-one, whose reputation was for careful, methodical work rather than theatrics. The defendants were the court administration and the private security firm that staffed the entrance, and their position was that the screening was neutral, that it followed a written policy, and that any differences in treatment were the result of individual circumstances, not a pattern.

Celeste had read the briefs twice. She had read the declarations, the screening logs, the policy manual, the expert report on disparate impact. She had made notes in the margins, questions she wanted to ask, points she wanted the parties to address. She did not have a conclusion yet, and she did not want one. A judge who walked into a hearing with her mind made up was not a judge at all. She wanted to hear the witnesses, to watch them answer, to weigh their credibility in the room, in person, where the law was supposed to be lived.

She turned onto Courthouse Square and saw the building rise ahead of her, a limestone structure with tall columns and a wide set of steps, built in an era when courthouses were meant to look like temples. The Magnolia Falls Federal Courthouse had been her workplace for eighteen years, and she knew it the way a person knows a house they have lived in for a long time: the squeak of the third stair, the draft in the hallway outside Courtroom Three, the way the light fell through the tall windows in the late afternoon. She parked in the judges' lot behind the building, as she always did, and gathered her bag.

News in the same category

They Cut the Judge's Braids in Her Own Courthouse — Then All Rise Echoed Through the Trial That Followed Them

45 Part