They Cut the Judge's Braids in Her Own Courthouse — Then All Rise Echoed Through the Trial That Followed Them

Chapter 25

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Marcus Bell asked Denise what had changed, if anything, after she filed a complaint about the headwrap incident, and Denise said that she had received a letter acknowledging her complaint and then nothing for several months, and that when she called to ask about it, she was told that the matter had been reviewed and that no violation had been found. She said she had not been surprised, exactly, because she had heard similar stories from other people in her neighborhood, but she had been disappointed, because she had believed that a written complaint in a federal building would be taken seriously. She said she had kept coming to the courthouse anyway, because her work required it and because she refused to let an unfair screening stop her from being present for her neighbors, but she had learned to arrive earlier than she needed to, to allow extra time for the secondary line, and to wear her hair in a style that would not draw a second look, and she said that last part with a pause, as if she were hearing how wrong it sounded even as she said it.

When Marcus Bell asked her why she had agreed to testify in this hearing, Denise looked directly at the panel and said that she had agreed because Judge Celeste Warren had been treated in a way that Denise recognized, and because Denise believed that if a federal judge could be stopped and disbelieved in her own courthouse, then ordinary people had even less protection. She said she did not want revenge against any officer, and she did not want anyone to lose their job without a fair process, but she wanted the rules to be written down and followed the same way for everyone, and she wanted the people who screened visitors to be trained to understand that a headwrap, a braid, a long skirt, a walker, or a young Black man's presence in a courthouse was not a reason for suspicion. She wanted, she said, for the next woman who came through that door with a headwrap to be treated the way Denise wished she had been treated, with a brief, respectful check and a clear explanation, and then allowed to go on her way.

The panel's questions were careful and respectful. One member asked Denise whether she had ever been told, in writing, what the screening rules were, and Denise said no, she had never seen a written list posted at the entrance or given to visitors, and she had only learned what was expected by being stopped and corrected. Another member asked whether she believed the officers who had stopped her had acted out of personal animus or out of a lack of training and oversight, and Denise answered thoughtfully, saying that she could not know what was in another person's heart, and that she did not want to guess, but that she knew what the pattern looked like from where she stood, and that a pattern repeated often enough became a policy whether anyone had written it down or not. She said that training mattered, and supervision mattered, and written rules mattered, because without them, people fell back on habit and assumption, and habit and assumption were not fair.

When the cross-examination began, the attorney for the officers was polite but persistent, asking Denise whether she could be certain about the dates she had given, whether she might have misunderstood a standard security procedure, whether she had any proof beyond her own memory that she had been directed to a different line. Denise answered each question without defensiveness, conceding where her memory was incomplete and holding firm where it was clear. She said she understood that security required checks, and she was not asking for security to be abandoned, only for it to be applied consistently and respectfully. She said she had no recording of the headwrap incident, and she wished she had, but she had not thought to record it at the time because she had not expected to be treated that way in a courthouse. She said she had told her husband and her sister about it that same evening, and she had written a note about it in her journal, and she offered to provide the journal entry if the panel wished to see it. The attorney thanked her and moved on, and Denise remained composed, her hands still folded, her voice steady.

After Denise stepped down, the hearing took a short recess, and Celeste stood in the hallway outside the courtroom with Maya Thompson, talking quietly about what Denise had said. Maya Thompson was twenty-two, a second-year law student, bright and earnest, and Celeste had taken her on as an intern that summer because she saw in Maya Thompson a seriousness about the law that reminded her of herself at that age. Maya Thompson asked Celeste how she had learned to listen the way Denise had listened, without interrupting, without correcting, without making the story about herself, and Celeste smiled and said that listening was a skill that had to be practiced like any other, and that the courtroom rewarded people who could listen well, because the truth often arrived in a quiet voice rather than a loud one.

News in the same category

They Cut the Judge's Braids in Her Own Courthouse — Then All Rise Echoed Through the Trial That Followed Them

45 Part