Officer Kyle Preston's response was different. Preston, twenty-nine, had been the youngest of the three officers, and he had begun to doubt what had happened even before Samuel Grant's investigation, telling a colleague that he had felt uneasy about the way Celeste had been treated and that he had not spoken up at the time because he had deferred to Captain Royce Tanner's authority. In his disciplinary hearing, Preston testified honestly and at length, describing what he had seen, what he had thought at the time, and what he had come to understand since. He said he had doubted Celeste's identification at first because he had not recognized her, and that he had been wrong to do so, because a judge's identification, like any person's identification, deserved to be checked respectfully and verified through proper channels, not doubted because of unfamiliarity. He said he had followed Tanner into the private security room because he believed he was following orders, but that he had felt uncomfortable when the clippers were produced, and that he had not objected because he was afraid of contradicting his captain in front of a detainee.
Preston said he regretted his silence, and he said he understood now that following orders did not excuse failing to speak up when something was wrong. He said he had spoken to Samuel Grant voluntarily, without being compelled, and that he had provided a full account, even where it reflected poorly on himself, because he believed that honesty was the only way to restore trust. He said he was willing to accept the consequences of his actions, including additional training, supervision, and a formal reprimand, and he said he wanted to learn how to handle similar situations differently, including how to verify identification respectfully, how to request a supervisor review when a situation was uncertain, and how to intervene when a colleague was acting in a way that could cause harm. He said he had thought a great deal about Celeste Warren's braids, and about what they meant to her, and he said he was sorry for his part in what had happened, and that his apology was not offered to avoid discipline, but because he meant it.
Celeste listened to Preston's testimony with close attention, and when it was finished, she told Marcus Bell that she respected Preston's honesty, and that she believed his willingness to tell the truth, even when it was difficult, was a sign that he could learn and change. She said she did not want Preston to be treated as if his honesty counted for nothing, but she also said she did not want his honesty to erase the need for accountability, because accountability and honesty went together, and a fair process would recognize both. Chief Judge Patricia Cole, overseeing the process, noted Preston's cooperation in the record, and said that cooperation would be considered as a factor in determining the appropriate outcome, alongside the seriousness of the incident and the need to protect the public's trust.
Officer Sean Barrett's disciplinary hearing was quieter and more difficult. Barrett, thirty-four, had remained silent throughout the investigation and the hearing, declining to testify in his own defense and declining to answer questions from Samuel Grant beyond a brief written statement in which he said he had acted in accordance with instructions from Captain Royce Tanner. His attorney argued that Barrett had followed his superior's orders and that he should not be held responsible for decisions made by Tanner, but the panel and the disciplinary authorities asked whether following orders excused an officer from responsibility when the orders led to an unjustified detention and the cutting of a person's hair without consent. Barrett did not answer that question directly, and his silence left the record with a gap that the process would have to address through the available evidence, including the footage and the testimony of others who had been present.
Frank Delgado, as Director of Court Security, testified in the disciplinary process about the need for clear lines of responsibility, saying that every officer, regardless of rank, had a duty to act lawfully and respectfully, and that deference to a superior did not remove that duty. He said that training would need to emphasize that duty, and that officers would need to know how to raise a concern, how to request a supervisor review from someone outside the immediate chain, and how to document a situation when they believed an order might be wrong. He said that Barrett's silence was understandable as a legal strategy, but that it made it harder to assess his understanding and his willingness to change, and that the disciplinary outcome would need to reflect both the evidence of his actions and the absence of any acknowledgment or plan for improvement.