While the disciplinary process continued, Marcus Bell and Celeste, with input from Denise Carter, Frank Delgado, Teresa Alvarez, and Samuel Grant, prepared a set of reform proposals to present to the panel and to Chief Judge Patricia Cole. The proposals were detailed and practical, designed to be implemented in Magnolia Falls and to serve as a model for other courthouses. The first proposal was for written screening rules, posted at every entrance in clear language, in English and Spanish, explaining what visitors could expect, what they would be asked to do, what they could ask for, including a private screening, and how to file a complaint if they believed they had been treated unfairly. The rules would state explicitly that identification would be verified respectfully, that a person's appearance, hairstyle, head covering, or clothing was not, on its own, a reason for secondary screening, and that any secondary screening would be documented with a brief written note explaining the reason.
The second proposal was for body cameras, to be worn by all courthouse security officers during screening and during any detention or private security check, with clear rules about when the cameras would be on, how the footage would be stored, who could access it, and how long it would be retained. The proposal addressed privacy concerns, stating that footage from private screenings would be handled with additional safeguards, and that footage would be available to investigators, to the Judicial Council, and to a complainant who requested it through a fair process. Frank Delgado supported the proposal, saying that body cameras protected both visitors and officers, because they created an objective record and reduced disputes about what had happened, and Teresa Alvarez agreed, noting that other federal facilities had adopted body cameras with positive results.
The third proposal was for supervisor review, requiring that any detention beyond a brief screening, any decision to take a person to a private room, and any use of restraints be approved by a supervisor who was not directly involved in the initial stop, and be documented in writing within a short time. The proposal also required that a supervisor review any complaint within a set period, and that the complainant receive a written response explaining what had been found and what action, if any, had been taken. Denise Carter spoke strongly in favor of this proposal, saying that her earlier complaint had gone unanswered for months, and that a timely, written response would have made a difference in her trust, even if the outcome had not been what she hoped.
The fourth proposal was for hair and identity respect training, a program developed with input from community members, including Denise Carter, and from experts in cultural competency, that would teach officers about the significance of braids, headwraps, hijabs, and other hairstyles and coverings, about the importance of asking before touching a person's hair or covering, about offering a private room, and about explaining each step before it was taken. The training would include scenarios based on real incidents, including the testimony heard in the hearing, and it would be repeated annually, with refresher sessions and assessments to ensure that officers understood and could apply what they had learned. Maya Thompson, who had helped draft the language for this proposal, said that the training should not be a single lecture, but an ongoing conversation, with officers and community members learning from each other.
The debate over the reform proposals was thorough and, at times, spirited, but it remained respectful. Some officers and their representatives raised concerns about the cost of body cameras, about the time required for supervisor review, and about whether written rules might limit an officer's ability to respond to a genuine security threat. Frank Delgado addressed those concerns directly, saying that the proposals were designed to support security, not to weaken it, and that clear rules and documentation made security stronger, because they made it more consistent and more trusted. Teresa Alvarez added that a courthouse that was trusted by the community was a safer courthouse, because people were more likely to cooperate, to report concerns, and to attend proceedings when they believed they would be treated fairly.
Marcus Bell presented data from other courthouses that had adopted similar reforms, showing that complaints had decreased, that screening times had not increased significantly, and that officers had reported feeling more confident when they had clear rules to follow. Denise Carter spoke about the community's perspective, saying that people did not ask for special treatment, only for equal treatment, and that written rules, body cameras, supervisor review, and training were not burdens, but protections for everyone. Celeste, speaking as a witness and as a judge who had returned to the bench, said that she supported the proposals because they were fair, practical, and grounded in the testimony the panel had heard, and because they addressed not only what had happened to her, but what had happened to Denise Carter and to the other witnesses who had testified.