The charges were reported in the local news that week, in a short item that named no one beyond the offices involved, and the effect on Desert Bloom Estates was immediate and strange. People who had crossed the street to avoid talking about the fines now stopped me at the mailbox to ask, quietly, whether what they had heard was true. Bill Hart came over one evening with a folder of his own, thinner than mine, containing the letters about his faded mailbox. June stood beside him in the driveway, her arms folded, listening while Bill told me that he had paid his fine because he had not wanted trouble, and that he had felt foolish ever since for paying it.
"You weren't foolish, Bill," I said. "You were tired. There's a difference."
Anne Sullivan came to see us on a Saturday morning, carrying a clipboard and a stack of printed forms, and she did not sit down until she had explained why she was there. The recall petition, she said, was not her idea alone. It had grown out of conversations at mailboxes and on porches, out of neighbours comparing letters and realising they were not alone. The petition asked for a special meeting and a vote to remove George Halvorsen and Dennis Kline from the board. Anne would not be a petitioner herself, she explained, because as secretary she needed to be able to certify the process fairly, but she would answer questions, and she would make sure the signatures were counted honestly.
"How many do you need?" Elaine asked.
"Enough to show the board cannot ignore it," Anne said. "And then enough to win."
I signed, and Elaine signed, and over the following week the clipboard travelled from house to house along Saguaro Court and through the wider streets of Desert Bloom Estates. I saw it on Bill Hart's porch, and later on Dana Whitfield's kitchen counter, and once in the hands of a man I recognised only vaguely from the community pool, who held it carefully as if it were something fragile. People did not sign loudly or angrily. Most of them signed quietly, read the wording twice, asked a question or two, and handed the clipboard back. Some asked whether signing would put them on a list. Anne's answer, when I heard her give it, was plain: "The list is the point. If we all sign alone, nothing changes. If we sign together, the board has to listen."
When the count was finished, Anne called a meeting in the community room at the management office. The room was too small for the crowd, and people stood along the walls and spilled into the hallway, fanning themselves with the printed agendas Karen Doyle had set out on a folding table. The air conditioning in the room laboured against the July heat, and the smell of coffee from a pot in the corner mixed with the faint chemical smell of the carpet. Anne stood at the front with Karen beside her, and she read the result in a clear voice that carried to the back of the room.
"One hundred and eighty-nine of two hundred and twenty-five households are represented in this petition," she said. "That is the number. It has been checked twice."
The recall vote itself was held two weeks later, in the same room, with paper ballots and a locked box and two volunteers from outside the board to count them. I arrived early with Elaine, and we took seats near the middle, where we could see the table at the front without being in anyone's way. Halvorsen was not there. Kline was not there either. Their absence was noted without comment, and the meeting proceeded as Anne had promised it would: orderly, dull in the best sense, with every step explained before it was taken. Voters filed past the table, signed the register, took a ballot, marked it behind a folding screen, and dropped it into the box. The box filled slowly. The room grew warmer as the afternoon went on, and someone propped the door open to let in a little air from the hallway.
When the counting began, the volunteers worked at a table in full view of the room, calling out each ballot and stacking it in one of two piles. I watched Elaine's hands in her lap, still and folded, and I thought about how many evenings that summer we had sat in a hot house waiting for something to change, and how strange it was to watch change happen in such an ordinary way, with paper and pencils and a folding screen.
Anne read the final tally aloud, and her voice did not shake.
"One hundred and seventy-one in favour of removal," she said. "Eighteen against."
For a moment nobody moved. Then Bill Hart stood up, and then Dana, and then the room stood, not cheering, but standing, as if standing were the only adequate response. Halvorsen and Kline were removed from the board that afternoon. Anne Sullivan, as secretary and the remaining board member with the longest service, became interim president until a new election could be held. She accepted with a short speech that I remember almost word for word, because it was so unlike the speeches Halvorsen used to give.