Voss's lawyer, a man named in the filings as her defence counsel, argued first that the footage had been staged. It was the same claim Voss had made to Detective Reyes on the night she was interviewed: that I had arranged the scene, that the figure in the video was not her, that the whole thing was a performance designed to make her look guilty. Mark told me about the argument over the phone one evening while I stood at the kitchen window looking out at the condenser pad, now lit by a small motion light Miguel had helped me install.
"He says you staged it, Peter," Mark said. "He says the camera was placed to catch a story, not a crime."
"Then let him explain the wire," I said.
"That is exactly what Vasquez intends to do," Mark said.
Detective Omar Reyes gave his deposition in a conference room at the county attorney's office, and Mark was present for it. Afterwards Mark described it to me in detail, because he knew I needed to hear how it had gone. Reyes spoke, Mark said, the way he had spoken to me on my porch that summer: plainly, without flourish, sticking to what he had seen and what he had logged. He described the tote found in Voss's garage, matching the tote in the trail-camera footage in size, colour, and wear. He described the gloves, and how the fragment snagged on our shared fence matched them in material and stitching. He described Voss's own words to him, the rattlesnake explanation, and the fact that she had offered no explanation at all for the wire cutters, which had been found in the same tote, still bearing traces consistent with copper.
Miguel Torres gave his deposition a week later, in the same room, and his testimony was, in Mark's word, "methodical." Miguel brought his photographs, his measurements, and his service records, and he walked the lawyers through them one by one. He showed the nick on the copper suction line from the first incident, and the clean cut on the control wire from the second, and the combed-flat fins and the vented refrigerant from the third. He explained, in language a jury could follow, why a homeowner's own equipment failure does not cut a wire cleanly, does not remove a capacitor, and does not leave the same tool-mark pattern three times. He explained that the marks were fresh, straight, and tool-made, and that the pattern repeated because the same tool had been used each time.
"Did the defence shake him?" I asked Mark.
"No," Mark said. "They tried. They asked whether an animal could have done it, whether heat could have done it, whether age could have done it. Miguel answered each question the same way he answered me on your pad that first day: with what he saw, and with what he measured. He did not guess. He did not exaggerate. That is why his report holds up."
The argument that defeated the staging claim most completely, Mark told me, was not any single piece of testimony. It was the second camera card. When Voss had returned at night to disable the trail camera, she had believed she was dealing with a single recording device. She had not known, and could not have known, that the camera kept recording on a second card even after the first was disturbed, and that Sofia's phone video from the upstairs window captured the same night from a different angle. The two recordings matched, second by second, in a way that no staging could explain, because no one staging a scene would film it twice from two places they did not know about, or would think to fake the time stamps on both. When Vasquez laid the two recordings side by side in the pre-trial hearing, Mark said, the defence counsel stopped interrupting and began taking notes instead.
Halvorsen's counter-suit arrived in the middle of that waiting period, and it arrived, like his fines, as a letter that tried to sound larger than it was. He sued me for defamation, claiming that I had damaged his reputation by telling neighbours and officials that he had backdated rules and protected Voss, and by repeating, as he put it, false claims about the board's finances. Mark read the filing at his desk while I sat across from him, and he did not look worried. He looked, if anything, mildly annoyed, the way a man looks at a job that will take time but will not change the outcome.
"He is suing you for saying what the minutes now show to be true," Mark said. "That is a difficult case to bring, Peter, and a harder one to win."
Ellison's response was filed within two weeks, and it was built, page by page, on documents Halvorsen himself had signed or that the board had now corrected. Mark attached the duplicate minutes Anne had kept, and the corrected minutes the new board had published, and the bank records showing the transfer to Sonoran Cooling and Repair, and the letters Halvorsen had sent me, with their identical wording and their backdated rule date. He argued, simply, that truth is not defamation, and that a man cannot sue for harm to a reputation that his own records contradict.