What the Cut Wire Proved on Saguaro Court

Chapter 36

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

"Could heat alone have caused this damage, Mr. Torres?" Vasquez asked.

"No," Miguel said. "Heat makes metal expand, and age makes parts wear. Neither one cuts a wire in a straight line, and neither one removes a capacitor and sets it aside."

"Could an animal have done it?"

"An animal chews," Miguel said. "It does not use cutters. The marks here are tool marks, not teeth marks. I have seen both, and they do not look alike."

The defence cross-examined him at length, asking about other possible causes, about other houses he had serviced, about whether he could be absolutely certain, and Miguel answered each question without rising to the bait. He said what he knew, and he said what he did not know, and he did not pretend that certainty meant more than it did. When he stepped down, he glanced at me briefly on his way past, and I nodded to him, and that small exchange felt like more thanks than I could have put into words.

Anne Sullivan testified after Miguel, and her testimony was the quiet hinge on which much of the case turned. She brought the duplicate minutes she had kept, and the corrected minutes the new board had published, and she laid them out, in Vasquez's careful sequence, so that the jury could see the difference between what had been claimed and what had actually happened. She explained, in her measured way, that the emergency meeting of the eighteenth of June had never taken place, that she had not attended it because there had been no meeting to attend, and that the minutes recording it had been prepared afterwards and presented as if they were contemporaneous. She explained that she had kept her own duplicate set because she had feared, correctly as it turned out, that the official record would be altered. She did not speak angrily about Halvorsen or Kline. She spoke as a secretary speaks about records: with precision, and with regret that precision had become necessary.

"Why did you keep the duplicates, Mrs. Sullivan?" Vasquez asked.

"Because the minutes are supposed to be the truth of what happened in the room," Anne said. "If the minutes are wrong, then everything that follows from them is wrong too. I kept them so that, one day, someone could check."

Voss took the stand on the third day, and the courtroom, which had been orderly throughout, grew still in a different way. She wore a dark dress and a light jacket, and she held herself upright, as if posture alone could carry her through what was coming. Her lawyer led her gently through her account: that she had been concerned about a rattlesnake near the fence line, that she had gone out at night to check, that she had carried gloves for protection, and that she had never intended to damage anything. She said she had not cut any wire, had not loosened any disconnect, and had not known anything about the capacitor. She said the footage must have been misunderstood, or taken out of context, or, as her lawyer had argued before the trial, staged by someone who wanted her to look guilty.

Vasquez rose for cross-examination, and she did not raise her voice. She began with the tote.

"Mrs. Voss," she said, "is this your tote?"

A photograph appeared on the screen: the tote from the trail-camera footage, beside a photograph of a tote found in Voss's garage. They were the same in colour, in size, in the fraying at one handle, in the faded stain near the bottom seam.

Voss hesitated. "I own a tote like that," she said. "Many people own totes like that."

"And these gloves?" Vasquez asked, and another pair of photographs appeared: the gloves in the footage, and the gloves found in her home, and a close image of the fragment snagged on our shared fence, with its stitching and its material visible under magnification.

"I wear gloves in the garden," Voss said.

"And the wire cutters?" Vasquez asked. "Were you carrying wire cutters to check for a rattlesnake, Mrs. Voss?"

Voss looked down at her hands. "I carry tools sometimes," she said. "I do not remember exactly what I had that night."

"You do not remember," Vasquez repeated, not as a question, "whether you were carrying the wire cutters that appear in the footage, in your hand, at one seventeen in the morning, beside Mr. Anders's condenser, while wearing gloves and carrying a tote?"

"I was frightened," Voss said, and her voice rose slightly. "There was a snake. I have told you that."

"Did you call anyone about the snake?" Vasquez asked. "Did you call animal control, or a neighbour, or the sheriff's department, that night or the next morning?"

"No," Voss said.

"Did you mention a snake to anyone at all, before Detective Reyes asked you about that night?"

News in the same category

What the Cut Wire Proved on Saguaro Court

45 Part