What the Cut Wire Proved on Saguaro Court

Chapter 41

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Judge Sandoval took his time before he spoke, and when he did, his voice filled the room without rising. He said he had considered the jury's verdicts, the pre-sentence reports, the statements of the victims, and the arguments of counsel, and that he intended to impose sentences that were proportionate, that acknowledged cooperation where it had been given, and that protected the community going forward. He began with Margaret Voss, and I felt Elaine's hand tighten on mine as he said the words. He sentenced Voss to four years, with two years to serve and two years suspended, plus probation, and four hundred hours of community service. He said the community service was not a punishment to be resented, but a chance to give back to a neighborhood she had harmed, and that the court expected her to complete it honestly. Voss nodded, her eyes down, and a deputy stepped closer, and I looked away, because there was nothing satisfying in watching a fifty-eight-year-old woman led toward a sentence, only the sober knowledge that the law had done what it was supposed to do.

He turned next to George Halvorsen, and his tone did not soften. He said Halvorsen, as president, had held the trust of two hundred and twenty-five households, and had used that trust to backdate a rule, to shield the person who had damaged my equipment, and to fine me for the very damage she had caused. He sentenced Halvorsen to five years, with three years to serve and two years suspended, plus probation. Halvorsen's face went pale, and his lawyer put a hand on his arm, and for a moment I thought about the board meetings where Halvorsen had cut me off mid-sentence, and about how final a gavel sounded compared to a chairman's interruption. Judge Sandoval said the longer custodial portion reflected Halvorsen's leadership role in the fraud, and that a man who writes the rules cannot then hide behind them. He said probation would follow, with conditions the court would set in writing, and that Halvorsen was to have no further involvement in the management of Desert Bloom Estates or any other homeowners association during that period. I wrote none of that down. I did not need to. Mark Ellison was writing it down for us, in his neat hand, on a legal pad, and I knew he would go over every line with us later, when the emotion of the room had settled.

Dennis Kline came next, and the judge's manner shifted, just slightly, the way a teacher's voice shifts when a student has finally told the truth after a long silence. He acknowledged Kline's testimony, that Kline had confirmed the reserve transfer was Halvorsen's instruction and that Barnett had split the duplicate payments, and he said cooperation mattered, but it did not erase the offense. He sentenced Kline to two years, suspended in full, plus probation and three hundred hours of community service. Kline closed his eyes for a second, and his shoulders dropped, and I felt a complicated pity for him, because he was sixty-five years old and had traded his good name for a seat at a table where he was never really in charge. The judge said the community service was to be completed through a program approved by probation, and that Kline, like Halvorsen, was to have no role in association management while on probation. Kline nodded, and his lawyer whispered something to him, and he nodded again, and I thought that, of all the men in that room, he was the one who most looked like a man who had finally stopped pretending.

Steve Barnett was last. Judge Sandoval looked at him for a long moment before he spoke, and he said a contractor who overbills a neighborhood is not merely careless with invoices, but careless with people's trust in their own homes. He sentenced Barnett to eighteen months, suspended in full, and he added two conditions that drew a murmur from the back of the room, because they were practical in a way that prison time alone would not have been. Barnett was banned from homeowners association contracts for five years, and his contractor's licence was suspended for two years. The judge said the licence suspension would be reported to the licensing board, and that Barnett could petition for reinstatement only after he had completed restitution and complied with probation. Barnett stared at his hands, and I thought about the Sonoran Cooling van that had come and gone from our street, and about the invoices with no work orders behind them, and about Miguel Torres, who had never once billed us for work he had not done. It seemed right, somehow, that the sentence for a man who had made his money from contracts should be measured, in part, in contracts he could no longer take.

News in the same category

What the Cut Wire Proved on Saguaro Court

45 Part