What the Deputy Smashed on Holloway Road

Chapter 13

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Over the next four days the rain came as it does in late December in Georgia, not in one dramatic storm but in steady, soaking spells that left the gravel of the lot dark and the air smelling of wet earth. I went back to the lot on the second day with Maya, and the seats were wetter, and the water had begun to darken the leather in patches where it had pooled in the seams. I went back on the third day with James, and the smell inside the car had changed, a damp, close smell that anyone who has ever left a car open in rain will recognise at once, and the glass on the seats was now sitting in shallow water in the footwells. I photographed the car each time, at the same angles, so that the change could be seen day by day, and I wrote down the weather each time, the time, and who was with me, because a series of photographs with times is harder to argue with than a single photograph taken once. On the fourth day I went back alone in the morning, early, before the lot office opened, and stood outside the fence and looked at the Bentley through the wire, and the rain had left its mark plainly: the leather seats were soaked through in places, the stitching was dark with water, and the interior that I had kept immaculate for two years looked like a car that had been left out to weather on purpose. I did not go in that morning. I stood there and took photographs through the fence, and I wrote down the date and the time and the fact that this was the fourth day the car had sat uncovered, and I felt a quiet, steady anger that was different from the shock of the night on Holloway Road. Shock is fast. This anger was slow, and it had paperwork behind it, and it was going to last as long as the file did.

It was during those four days that the other half of the story began to move, the half that had nothing to do with rain and everything to do with who knew what, and when. I had not announced my election win during the stop. I had identified myself only as a driver, I had asked calmly what the violation was, and I had kept my hands visible, and Brennan had treated me as a stranger on his road. That changed, as such things do in a small county, not with a single announcement but with a series of small, telling moments. A clerk at the courthouse mentioned my name to a deputy. A transition meeting attendee mentioned that the woman in the Bentley was the sheriff-elect. A reporter from the county paper called the sheriff's office to ask about a stop on Holloway Road. By the second day after the stop, Brennan knew. By the third day, Whitaker knew, and the knowledge changed the way both men behaved, because a deputy who smashes the windows of a stranger has a problem, and a deputy who smashes the windows of the woman who will be his sheriff on 3 January has a much larger one. I learned about their change of behaviour the way you learn most things in Ellery: not from them directly, but from the paper trail they left behind when they tried to tidy it up. James requested a copy of the official dispatch log for the night of the stop, in writing, through the proper channel, and when the copy arrived it did not match what I remembered, and it did not match what my notebook said. The stop was not logged at 12:04 a.m. The time had been altered, and the entry about Brennan's body camera was missing altogether, as if the camera had never been part of the night. The tow call at 3:15 a.m., the call Hollis had made after my release, was missing too. Three facts, all gone or changed, all from the same night, all from the same log, and I sat at my kitchen table with James and Maya and read the altered copy twice, slowly, and then I put it in the folder next to my own notebook pages, where the difference between the two could be seen side by side.

James asked for the body-camera file next, also in writing, also through the proper channel, and the answer came back more slowly than the log had, and when it came it was shorter: no file could be produced for Brennan's camera for that night. No footage, no file number, no explanation that held together from one sentence to the next. One clerk said the camera had not been activated. Another said the file had been corrupted in upload. A third said there was no record of a camera being issued for that shift, which I knew, from twenty-three years of patrol procedure, was not how cameras or shifts worked. I wrote down each answer, with the date and the time and the name of the person who gave it, because three different explanations for the same missing file are themselves a kind of evidence. Brennan's camera had been switched off at 11:58 p.m., six minutes before the stop, according to the record I would later see confirmed, but at that point in the story all I knew, from my own side of the paper trail, was that the official log had been altered and the camera file was missing, and that both gaps pointed at the same night and the same deputy. Whitaker, when James wrote to him directly, replied that the log discrepancy was a clerical matter, that times were sometimes corrected during transcription, and that the camera issue was a technical fault that the office was looking into. He did not mention the tow. He did not mention the windows. He did not mention my injuries. His letter was polite, formal, and empty in exactly the places where a sheriff's letter about a stop should have been full, and I read it at my kitchen table and put it in the folder with the altered log, because a letter that avoids the facts is also a fact.

News in the same category

What the Deputy Smashed on Holloway Road

45 Part