What the Deputy Smashed on Holloway Road

Chapter 35

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

After Rosa came Tanya Brooks, the night-shift nurse who had been driving home from Ellery General when she came upon the stop. She was thirty-nine, and she testified in the plain, factual way nurses testify, describing what she saw and what her dashcam recorded without adding colour to it. Her dashcam, facing forward, had recorded the stop, the working taillights, my calm behaviour at the window, and Brennan walking around the Bentley with the baton, and Ellison played the footage for the jury on a screen at the front of the courtroom. Watching it was strange, because I had lived the night but I had never seen it from the road, from behind, the way Tanya's camera had seen it, and there was my black Bentley in the pull-off with its taillights lit and steady, and there was Brennan's cruiser behind it, and there was the small figure of me at the window with my hands visible, and then the figure of Brennan walking around the car with something in his hand, and the jury watched the windows break in the footage the way I had watched them break from the cruiser, except now it was on a screen and it was evidence and it could not be argued away. Tanya told the jury she had not intervened on the roadside, because a nurse driving home alone at midnight does not step into a stop between a deputy and a driver, but that she had driven on, saved the footage, and handed it to the Georgia Bureau of Investigation, and that she had done so because what she had seen did not match what a lawful stop should look like. Reece asked her if her camera could have missed something, and she said any camera can miss something, but that hers had not missed the taillights or the baton, and those were the things that mattered. I was grateful to her in a way that went beyond the case, because she had done the brave thing that looks small from the outside, which is to save what you saw and hand it to someone who can use it, even when you know the deputy in the footage works in your county.

Earl Simmons followed Tanya, and he was fifty-eight, the owner of Simmons Diner on Holloway Road, a man who had run a diner long enough to know most of the night traffic by sight, and whose security camera covered the roadside pull-off. He testified about his camera the way a man testifies about a piece of equipment he maintains himself, which was to say with exactness about where it pointed and when it recorded and how the footage was stored. Ellison played the diner footage too, and it showed the baton strikes more clearly than the dashcam had, because the camera was closer to the pull-off and higher up, and the jury could see Brennan's arm rise and fall and the glass break and fall, and then later in the same footage, the tow truck arriving at 3:15 a.m. and the Bentley being loaded and taken away in the dark. Earl said he had not watched the footage live that night, because he had been closing the diner, but that he had pulled it the next day when he heard what had happened, and had kept a copy and given a copy to the investigators. Reece asked him if the camera had sound, and Earl said it did not, and Reece tried to make something of that, but Earl said plainly that the picture was enough, that you did not need sound to see a man break six windows with a baton, and Judge Crawford did not stop him from saying it, because it was an answer to the question he had been asked. I liked Earl for that, and for the fact that he had not hesitated, the way some people in a small town hesitate when the person in the footage is a deputy they have served coffee to for years.

News in the same category

What the Deputy Smashed on Holloway Road

45 Part