Then Douglas Reece stood up for cross-examination, and the room changed its temperature in the small way a room does when the questions stop being friendly. He was polite, as I said, and he did not raise his voice, but he was thorough, and he went at the parts of my story that a defence attorney is paid to go at. He asked me if I had really kept my hands visible the whole time, and I said yes. He asked me if I had really been polite, and I said yes, and that my phone recording and the nurse's dashcam both showed a calm driver asking a reasonable question. He asked me why I had not announced that I was the sheriff-elect, and I said because I did not think a driver should have to announce an election result to be treated lawfully on the roadside, and because I did not want the stop to become about who I was instead of about what the law required. He pressed me on that, and asked if I had been testing Brennan, and I said no, that I had been driving home from a meeting, and that a test is something you plan, and I had not planned to be stopped at midnight on Holloway Road. He asked me about the second time I asked for the reason, and whether Brennan could reasonably have heard that as refusal, and I said I had asked a question, not refused an order, and that asking for the reason for a stop is not refusal, and that I had complied when he ordered me out, even though I did not agree with the order, because compliance on the roadside and complaint afterwards is what I had taught troopers for twenty-three years.
Reece asked me about the glass, and whether I had actually seen every strike from inside the cruiser, and I answered honestly, which was that I had seen Brennan walk around the car with the baton and had heard the strikes and seen the windows break in turn, and that the diner camera and the dashcam filled in any angle I could not see from the cruiser. He asked me about my injuries, and whether the cuts could have come from something other than the glass, and I said the cuts were shallow and consistent with glass, and that the hospital record said so, and that I had not claimed more than that. He asked me about my notebook, and whether I had written the times down that night or later, and I said I had written them down as soon as I could, and that the dispatch log and the cameras agreed with my times, so the notebook was not standing alone. He asked me, finally, whether I bore Brennan ill will because he had backed the losing candidate in the election, and I said I bore him no ill will for his vote, and that I had not brought this case because of an election, but because a deputy had smashed my car while I sat cuffed in his cruiser, and that would have been wrong no matter who had won. Judge Crawford watched Reece closely during all of this, and twice she sustained Ellison's objections when his questions went beyond what I had testified to, and once she told him to move on when he circled back to the same point for a third time. When he finished, I stepped down from the stand with my hands steady, and Maya caught my eye from the gallery and gave me a small nod, and James wrote something in his own notebook, and I sat down feeling the way you feel after a long shift, tired and relieved in equal measure.
The next witness was Rosa Delgado, and the courtroom settled again in a different way, because Rosa was not a person who sought attention, and everyone in the room seemed to know it. She was forty-three, a dispatcher who had worked in that small dispatch office on Courthouse Square for years, and she had kept a duplicate handwritten dispatch log at home because the official log had been altered before, and she had never altered her copy, never backdated it, and had handed it over only through her lawyer. Ellison walked her through it slowly, page by page, and Rosa answered in a clear, unhurried voice, pointing to entries with a steady hand. The duplicate log showed the stop logged at 12:04 a.m., Brennan's body camera switched off at 11:58 p.m., and Hollis's tow call at 3:15 a.m., and Rosa explained that each of those entries was missing or altered in the official log, and that she had kept her copy at home precisely because she had seen official entries change before and had not wanted to be left with nothing but her memory if it happened again. Reece cross-examined her about why she had not reported the alterations sooner, and Rosa said she had been afraid, and that fear in a small office where the sheriff backs the man you would be reporting is not a small thing, and that she had handed the log over through her lawyer when there was an outside investigation that could protect it. Judge Crawford let her finish that answer without interruption, and I thought about the dispatch office across the square, and about how much of this case had rested on one woman writing times down by hand at home because she did not trust the official record to stay true. My notebook and her log were not the same thing, but they were kin, and I respected her for keeping hers when it would have been easier to throw it away.