I described the smashing window by window, because that was how it happened and because each window mattered. He struck the driver window first, and the glass broke inward and fell onto the driver's seat and the floor. Then he walked to the front passenger side and struck that window, and the glass fell onto the passenger seat. Then he went to the rear side windows, first one side and then the other, and struck each in turn. Then he struck the rear window, and then the small quarter windows, six windows in all, and with a final strike he cracked the windshield in a star pattern that spread across the glass while the windshield itself held together. I told the jury about the sound, which was not one sound but a series of sharp cracks followed by the lighter sound of glass settling onto leather and onto the road, and about the cold air that came into the car through the broken windows, and about the way Brennan walked back toward the cruiser afterwards as if he had finished a task, and told me, through the cruiser window, that this was what happened when people did not listen on his road. I told them I did not answer him, because there was nothing useful to say to a man with a baton in his hand while I was cuffed in his cruiser, and because I had already decided that the place to answer him was not the roadside but the paperwork and the investigation that would follow. Ellison asked me if I had been able to protect the car, and I said no, that I had been cuffed in the cruiser and unable to move, and that the car had sat there with its windows broken and its interior open to the night.
Ellison then asked me about the holding cell, and I told the jury that after the roadside, Brennan drove me to the Pinewood County Sheriff's Office on Courthouse Square in Ellery, to the low brick building with the booking desk and the two holding cells and the small dispatch office, and that I was booked and put in a cell and held there until 2:38 a.m. I told them I was given a citation for alleged resisting and alleged failure to comply, and that I was released with no tow at first, and that I walked out of that building in the early hours of the morning with glass cuts on my left forearm and my left cheek, a bruised wrist, and a headache that sat behind my eyes like a weight. I told them I went to Ellery General Hospital that morning and was treated there, and that the injuries were shallow cuts and a bruise and a headache, no broken bones and no hospital stay, and I said that plainly because I did not want the jury to think I was claiming more than had happened. The facts were bad enough without exaggeration. A man in uniform had cuffed me, put me in his cruiser, and smashed every window in my car with a baton while I could not stop him, and then I had sat in a cell until nearly three in the morning on charges that would later be dropped. That was enough. I did not need to make it more.
Ellison asked me about the tow, and I told them that Hollis later had the Bentley towed by Calloway at 3:15 a.m. to the Calloway lot, where it sat uncovered in the rain for four days, and that the rain added water damage to seats that were already covered in glass. I told them Maya had seen the car there, and that when I saw it myself I understood for the first time the full cost of that night, not in money, though the money would matter later, but in the way a thing you have kept immaculate for two years can be ruined in one night by a man with a baton and then left out in the rain by the people who were supposed to be keeping it safe. I told them the citation was dropped on the second of January, the day before I took office, after the Georgia Bureau of Investigation review, and Ellison asked me if I had asked for it to be dropped because I was about to become sheriff, and I said no, that I had not asked for anything except a fair review, and that the review had found what the dashcam and the telematics and the diner camera had already shown, which was that the taillight was not broken and I had not been speeding.