With the sentences and the dismissal in place, the question of restitution could be set out in full, and Judge Crawford set it out in the plain arithmetic that I have always trusted more than speeches. The wider scheme, as proved at trial, amounted to two hundred ninety-four thousand three hundred dollars in impound kickbacks, inflated storage, and unlogged cash seizures across nineteen motorists over three years, including fifty-two thousand dollars in duplicate Calloway towing invoices and thirty-eight thousand four hundred dollars in cash seizures never logged. I have written those figures down here in words as well as I can, because the court record states them in figures, and because the point of restitution is that the money is counted, not described in general terms. The restitution ordered was two hundred ninety-four thousand three hundred dollars to the victims' fund, plus forty thousand eight hundred dollars to me. That second sum was made up of eighteen thousand seven hundred dollars for glass replacement, four thousand two hundred dollars for paint and body work, two thousand eight hundred and fifty dollars for a rental car, five thousand four hundred dollars for medical costs, and nine thousand six hundred and fifty dollars for lost wages and legal costs, and those parts add together to forty thousand eight hundred dollars in all. I checked the addition myself at James's table, the way I had checked every tow invoice and every storage charge that had come my way, and the total matched, and I wrote it down in my notebook under the date of the order, because a total that matches is a small mercy after months of charges that did not.
The glass figure was the largest part of my own restitution, and it should have been, because glass was what had been destroyed most completely on Holloway Road. Six windows had been smashed, and the windshield had been cracked in a star pattern, and replacing that glass in a car like mine is not a matter of fitting a single pane and calling the work done. The glass had to match, the seals had to be right, and the interior had to be cleaned of the fragments that had fallen onto the leather seats and into the seams where glass hides long after the visible pieces are gone. The paint and body work followed from the same night, because a baton swung around a car does not only break glass, and because a car left uncovered in rain needs work that goes beyond a wash. The rental car figure covered the time when my own car could not be driven, and the medical figure covered the treatment at Ellery General Hospital that morning for the shallow glass cuts to my left forearm and my left cheek, the bruised wrist from the cuffs, and the headache from the night. There were no broken bones, and there was no hospital stay, and I have never claimed otherwise, because exaggerating an injury would have weakened the true record, and the true record was strong enough. The lost wages and legal costs covered the work I missed and the help I needed to file complaints and to keep the paperwork straight, and James had kept that part of the file with the same care he kept everything else.
The victims' fund mattered to me as much as my own restitution, and in some ways more, because it reached beyond my car and my night and toward the nineteen motorists whose money had been taken in smaller and quieter ways over three years. A teacher overcharged for an impound, a delivery driver whose cash was never logged, a nurse held on a false charge, a farmer towed twice on the same night, and the other motorists whose names were in the trial record but whose stories were told only briefly, all belonged to that fund in the sense that the fund existed because their losses had been counted together and named as a scheme rather than treated as separate mistakes. Restitution to a fund does not undo a night in a holding cell or a tow that should never have happened, and I did not pretend to myself that it did. What it does is return money that was taken, and it does so under a court order, with an amount that can be checked, and that checking is the beginning of trust. I had spent twenty-three years in patrol work learning that people will accept a difficult outcome if they can see how it was reached, and they will not accept an easy outcome if the figures do not add up. The restitution figures added up, and I wrote them down, and I kept the paper.
James and I went through the restitution paperwork together, page by page, and he explained each page in the plain language he uses with family when the legal language would only get in the way. He showed me where the victims' fund was named, and where my own sum was broken into its parts, and where the order stated that the payments would be made under the court's supervision rather than left to private arrangement. I asked the questions I always ask when paperwork is put in front of me, about dates and about who holds the money and about what happens if a payment is missed, and he answered each one without rushing me, because he knows that I ask those questions not from doubt but from habit. A captain learns to ask who holds the key, who signs the log, and who checks the work, and a sheriff has to ask the same questions on a larger scale. By the time we finished, the file was in order, the totals matched, and the next step was not another court date but the work of the county itself, which is where a sheriff's office either earns trust or loses it, one log entry at a time.