What the Deputy Smashed on Holloway Road

Chapter 38

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The jury deliberated for two days, and those two days were the longest part of the whole trial for me, longer than my testimony and longer than the cross-examination, because there was nothing to do but wait. I thought often, during those two days, about the dispatch office across the square in Ellery and about Rosa sitting at her desk under a system that had asked her to keep a second log at home, and about Earl at his diner and Tanya on her night shifts, and about how many ordinary people had done one careful thing each, saving footage, keeping a copy, writing a time down, until those careful things added up to something a jury could hold. Maya stayed with me, and James checked in by phone, and I went for walks in the daylight and tried not to count the hours the way I had counted them in the holding cell. On the second afternoon, the court clerk called, and we went back to the courthouse, and the courtroom filled again, and Judge Crawford took her seat, and the foreperson of the jury stood. I remember the sound of the doors closing and the sound of my own breathing, and I remember Maya's hand finding mine in the gallery behind me, and I remember thinking about Marcus and about the Bentley, which was still being repaired then, and about the notebook in James's pocket. The foreperson read the verdicts one defendant at a time, and each verdict was guilty, Brennan guilty, Whitaker guilty, Hollis guilty, Calloway guilty, and the words landed in the room one after another with a weight that was not triumph but something steadier, like a door closing on a long draught. Brennan did not react visibly, Whitaker looked down at his hands, Hollis closed his eyes for a moment, and Calloway stared straight ahead. Judge Crawford thanked the jury for its service, reminded everyone that sentencing would follow at a later hearing, and adjourned the court, and the room emptied slowly, people speaking in low voices, and I sat for a moment longer before I stood, because the verdicts had been reached and the trial was over, and what came next would be a different kind of day, with its own paperwork and its own numbers, and I was not yet ready to think about it.

I kept my hands flat on the table in front of me while Judge Helen Crawford finished reading the sentences, because I had learned by then that stillness was the only way to hear every word exactly as it was said. The courtroom was not loud. It was the kind of quiet that comes after a long stretch of testimony, when people have heard enough to know what the facts are and are waiting only to hear what will be done about them. My brother James sat beside me with his notebook open and his pen already in his hand, and my daughter Maya sat on my other side with her hands folded in her lap, the way she had sat through the hardest days of the trial. I did not look around for the men who had brought us there. I looked at the judge, and I listened, and I wrote the times down in my own small notebook when there was a pause, because writing a time down exactly had become the habit that kept me steady, and because that habit was the reason we were sitting in that room at all.

Judge Crawford spoke first about Deputy Kyle Brennan, and she did not hurry through his sentence or soften it with extra explanation. She said that he would serve six years in federal prison, with four years to serve and two years suspended, followed by probation and four hundred hours of community service, and that he was removed from office and decertified as a peace officer in Georgia. I wrote each part of that down in order, the way I had written down the time of the stop and the time of the tow and every other time that mattered, because I wanted the record in my own hand to match the record of the court. Four years to serve and two years suspended made six years in all, and the probation and the community service would follow, and the removal and the decertification meant that he would not wear a badge in Georgia again. That last part mattered to me in a way that was quieter than anger. A badge is a trust, and when a man uses it to smash the windows of a woman who is sitting handcuffed in his cruiser, he has broken that trust in a way that cannot be repaired by an apology or by time alone. The court said so plainly, and I was glad that it did.

News in the same category

What the Deputy Smashed on Holloway Road

45 Part