What the Deputy Smashed on Holloway Road

Chapter 16

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

I told him what I had. I told him the stop was at 12:04 a.m. on 30 December on Holloway Road, just outside Ellery, on my way home from a late transition meeting at the Ellery community centre. I told him both taillights on my black 2022 Bentley Continental GT were working when I left that meeting and working when I was stopped, and that I had been driving 41 in a 45 zone, not fast, not drifting, not doing anything that would give a deputy a reason to light me up except that I was out late in a car that drew the eye. I told him I had kept my hands visible, that I had asked calmly what the violation was, that I had not announced who I was or what election I had won in November, that I had identified myself only as a driver at first because that was what the stop required and because I knew, from twenty-three years in uniform myself, that a roadside stop goes better when nobody is pulling rank in the dark. I told him Deputy Kyle Brennan had ordered me out, had called my second calm question a refusal, had handcuffed me, and had put me in his cruiser while he walked around my car with his expandable baton and smashed every window in turn. I said the order out loud in the order I remembered it, because order mattered: driver window, front passenger window, both rear side windows, rear window, and the small quarter windows, six windows in all, and then a final strike that cracked the windshield in a star pattern. Glass had fallen onto the leather seats and onto the road. He had told me, while I sat cuffed and unable to protect the car, that it was what happens when people do not listen on his road.

Ortiz wrote that sentence down without looking up, and then he looked up. He asked about my phone. I told him it had been in my coat pocket, recording audio, not video, because I had not wanted to hold it up and turn a stop into a confrontation. I had learned that habit on patrol: keep your hands where they can be seen, keep your voice level, and let the recording do the arguing later if arguing becomes necessary. The audio was not clean. A coat pocket does not make a studio. You could hear cloth rustle, you could hear my breathing, you could hear the cruiser door, you could hear the cuffs, and you could hear Brennan's voice when he came close enough. You could hear me ask for the reason a second time, polite, not raised. You could hear him answer with an order instead of a reason. You could hear the first strike, and then the pauses between strikes, because a man walking around a car does not smash six windows in one continuous motion. He stops, he shifts his feet, he finds the next pane, he swings again. On the audio those pauses were as telling as the glass itself, because they showed deliberation. This was not a single panicked blow. It was a walk around a car, window by window, while the owner sat cuffed in a cruiser and watched her car come apart in the dark.

My brother James, who is fifty and a civil attorney in Atlanta, sat with me for that first meeting and kept the paperwork in order the way he always has, without taking the story over. He made a copy of everything before it left my hands. He wrote the date and time on each copy in his own hand. He told Ortiz, plainly, that we would cooperate fully and that we would not be shopping the recording around town or handing copies to people who did not need them. That mattered to me. I was going to take office on 3 January, and I did not want my first act as sheriff-elect to be a public fight. I wanted a record that would stand up when nobody was shouting. Ortiz seemed to understand that. He did not press me to perform anger I did not feel in that room. What I felt was tired, and sore, and precise. My left forearm still carried shallow glass cuts, my left cheek carried a shallow cut of its own, my wrist was bruised from the cuffs, and I had a headache that had settled in behind my eyes and stayed there through the morning at Ellery General Hospital. No broken bones. No hospital stay. I said that to Ortiz exactly that way, because exaggeration would have weakened everything else. The injuries were small compared to what the car had taken, and they were still real, and they were still documented, and a nurse at Ellery General had cleaned the cuts and written them down while I sat in a chair trying not to shake from the cold that had finally caught up with me.

News in the same category

What the Deputy Smashed on Holloway Road

45 Part