What the Deputy Smashed on Holloway Road

Chapter 32

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The courthouse where the federal trial was held was bigger than our county courthouse across the square in Ellery, and it had the kind of heavy doors and high ceilings that make your footsteps sound louder than you intend. Judge Helen Crawford was sixty, and she ran her courtroom the way I had always thought a courtroom should be run, which is to say firmly, without raising her voice, and with no patience for speeches that were not evidence. She wore her robe the way a person wears a uniform they have earned, and she looked at each witness directly when they were sworn in, as if to remind them that the oath was not a formality. The prosecutor was a woman named Assistant United States Attorney Karen Ellison, who was thorough and unhurried, and who had spent hours with me going over the timeline before I ever took the stand. The defence attorney for Brennan was a man named Douglas Reece, who was polite in the courtroom and sharp in cross-examination, and who did not shout, which I respected even when I did not like what he was asking. Whitaker had his own lawyer, Calloway had his, and Hollis had his, and the four tables on the defence side made the room feel crowded in a way that reminded me of a station briefing where too many people have been pulled into one small room.

On the first morning of testimony, Ellison called me, and I walked to the stand with my notebook in my mind more than in my hand, because I had left the actual notebook with James, who sat behind me in the gallery with Maya. I was sworn in, I stated my name, Vivian Cole, and my age, forty-eight, and my former rank, captain in the Georgia State Patrol, with twenty-three years of service, and the fact that I had been elected sheriff of Pinewood County and would take office on the third of January. Ellison asked me to tell the jury, in my own words, what happened on Holloway Road on the night of the thirtieth of December, and I started where I always started, which was with the transition meeting at the Ellery community centre running late, and my drive home afterwards, and the quiet of Holloway Road just outside Ellery at just past midnight. I told them I was driving forty-one miles an hour in a forty-five zone, that both of my taillights were working, and that I knew both of those facts not only because I had been watching the road the way a patrol officer watches the road, but because the Bentley's telematics would later show my speed and because a nurse's dashcam would later show my taillights lit and steady. I told them Brennan's cruiser came up behind me and its lights came on, and I pulled over to the pull-off by Simmons Diner, and I kept my hands visible and my phone recording audio in my coat pocket, and I waited.

Ellison asked me what Brennan said when he came to my window, and I told her he said my taillight was broken and I had been speeding, and that I answered politely that I did not believe either was true, and asked him calmly what the violation was. I told the jury I identified myself only as a driver at first, because I did not want the stop to become about the election, and because a driver asking for the reason for a stop is entitled to an answer whether she is a sheriff-elect or not. I told them I asked a second time, still calmly, still with my hands where he could see them, and that Brennan then ordered me out of the car and said I was refusing a lawful order. I told them he handcuffed me, and that the cuffs were tight on my left wrist, and that he put me in the back of his cruiser, and that from there I could see the Bentley sitting in the pull-off with its lights still on and its engine still running, and I could see Brennan standing beside it with his expandable baton in his hand. The courtroom was very quiet then, in the way a room gets quiet when people are listening hard, and I kept my voice steady because I had told this part before, to Agent Ortiz and to Agent Raman, and steadiness was a kind of respect for the facts.

News in the same category

What the Deputy Smashed on Holloway Road

45 Part