The tenth produced a contact that lasted ninety seconds. An officer named Delacruz had walked over, said, “Afternoon, gentlemen, everything all right?”, heard “Yes, thank you,” said, “Enjoy the weather,” and walked away.
That ninety-second clip would also, eventually, go viral — about three weeks after the first one, pushed hard by police organizations, and fairly so. Moreno-Hale put it in the findings report as Exhibit 12 with a one-line caption: This is also the department.
The eleventh was Officer Ryan Caldwell.
What people got wrong, in the weeks afterward, was the assumption that Damon and Kelvin had been hoping for it.
They were not. Nobody who has done this work is hoping for it. There is nothing enjoyable about sitting on a bench while a frightened twenty-six-year-old points a weapon at your chest, and the fact that you know how it ends does not do nearly as much for your heart rate as you would imagine.
Damon’s monitor, later pulled for the record, showed his pulse at 141 at the moment the Taser came up.
Kelvin’s was 158.
There is a moment on Priya Raghavan’s video, around the three-minute mark, where Kelvin reaches up and adjusts the collar of his jacket. A great many people online read that gesture as arrogance — the cool guy straightening his collar before the reveal.
What he was actually doing was checking that the camera clipped under the collar had not shifted, because if it had, and if something went wrong in the next ten seconds, there would be no footage of the ten seconds from the only angle that showed his own hands.
He was making sure that if he died on that bench, nobody could say he had reached for something.
He said that, more or less, in testimony eight months later, and the room went very quiet, and a senator from Nebraska took off his glasses and set them on the table and did not put them back on for several minutes.
Two more things about the men on the bench, both of which matter later.
The first: Damon Wright had, in his jacket pocket, a folded piece of paper that he had carried on every observation for six years. It was a photocopy of a page from his own incident report from the convenience store, the one with the sentence subject became combative and was restrained.
He had never shown it to anyone except Kelvin, once, in a hotel bar in a city neither of them remembered the name of.
Kelvin had read it and handed it back and said, “Why do you carry it?”
And Damon had said, “So I remember what it costs to be the guy standing eight feet away.”
The second: at 3:51 p.m., about four minutes into the encounter, before the Taser came out, Damon had said something that is audible on Priya’s video only if you turn the volume all the way up, and which nobody noticed for nine days until an audio engineer in Toronto ran the file through a noise filter for fun and posted the result.
What Damon says, very quietly, to Kelvin, while Caldwell is talking about a report of suspicious activity, is:
“Give him a door.”
And Kelvin says, “I did. Twice.”
And Damon says, “Give him one more.”
Which is why, at 3:52, Kelvin says a sentence that makes no sense at all unless you know that: “Officer, there’s nothing here that has to go any further than this. You walk, we sit, everybody has a nice afternoon.”
Caldwell’s response, on the recording, is: “You don’t tell me how this goes.”
Nine million people heard that exchange and heard it as a taunt and a refusal.
It was a man offering an exit and a man refusing to take it.
Damon Wright, asked about it by a documentary crew a year and a half later, would say the only bitter thing he ever said on camera about the whole affair.
“Everybody wants to know what I was thinking when the Taser came up,” he said. “Nobody ever asks what I was thinking at 3:52. I was thinking, take the door, man. Please take the door.” He looked away from the camera, and then back. “I’ve been on his side of that. I know exactly how heavy that door is. It weighs about as much as everybody watching.” ## Chapter Five — Nineteen Minutes Out
Sergeant Daniel Vance made it in fourteen.
He parked behind Caldwell’s cruiser, got out without his hat, and stood for a moment taking in the north end of Riverside Park: the vehicles, the windbreakers, the yellow tape that somebody had strung between two trees for no reason Vance could determine, the civilians in clusters giving statements, the ice cream truck being waved out through the service gate by an agent who was apologizing as he did it.
Then he saw Alicia Moreno-Hale walking toward him across the grass with a portfolio under her arm, and he thought, with the particular clarity that arrives about four seconds too late in a career: Oh. It’s one of these.
“Sergeant Vance?”
“Yes, ma’am.”
“Alicia Moreno-Hale, Department of Justice.” She did not offer a credential; she offered a card. “Your officer is in his vehicle. He’s not detained. He hasn’t been questioned. I told my people to leave him alone until somebody from his chain of command arrived, and I’d like you to know that was my instruction and I’d like you to tell him it was my instruction, because he is going to spend the next several years believing that nobody in this field treated him fairly, and I would prefer that belief be slightly inaccurate.”
Vance looked at the card.
“How bad is it?”
“That depends entirely on what your department does in the next ninety days.”
“That’s not an answer.”
“It’s the only honest one I have.” She glanced back toward the bench. “Sergeant, I want to say one thing to you directly, off the record, and then I’m going to say nothing else to you without your city attorney present. Are we clear that this is off the record?”
“Yeah.”
“Your officer did not do anything today that he has not done before. Not once. Not twice. We have the data. The only difference today is who was sitting on the bench.” She let that settle. “That’s not a threat. That’s the finding. The question for your department is whether you spend the next two years telling the public he’s one bad apple, because if you do, you will lose, and it will cost this city somewhere between eleven and forty million dollars, and at the end of it you will sign the same agreement you could have signed voluntarily in September.”
Vance said nothing for a while.
Then: “Can I go talk to my guy?”
“Of course.”
Caldwell had his hands in his lap. The body camera had finally stopped, because he had finally remembered to stop it, and the small act of pressing the button had felt obscurely like a confession.
Vance opened the passenger door and got in and shut it.