A Rookie Cop Aimed a Taser at Two Men on a Park Bench — Then One Said, “Make Sure Your Camera Catches This Part.”

Chapter 18

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

MORENO-HALE: No, sir, and I want to explain why carefully, because I think the intuition behind the question is a reasonable one. Entrapment is inducing a person to commit a crime they were not predisposed to commit. We did not induce anything. We did not speak to Officer Caldwell. We did not approach him. We did not create a scenario designed to be suspicious. Two men sat on a bench in a public park in daylight and did not move. If that constitutes inducement, then the inducement is the existence of Black men in public.

HARCOURT: That’s a rhetorical flourish.

MORENO-HALE: It is, sir, and I’ll withdraw the flourish and keep the point. There is no act we performed that a citizen is not entitled to perform. The entire scenario was: exercise an ordinary right in an ordinary place. If that produces a constitutional violation, the violation was not caused by us.

HARCOURT: You ran it eleven times and got one incident.

MORENO-HALE: That’s correct.

HARCOURT: One in eleven. Nine percent. Would you accept a hospital that killed nine percent of its patients?

MORENO-HALE: No, sir.

HARCOURT: Then why should I accept a statistic that says ninety-one percent of these officers did the right thing as proof that the department is broken?

MORENO-HALE: Because the eleven observations are not the evidence, Congressman. They’re the reason we were allowed to look at the evidence. The evidence is four years of the department’s own records, which show a search threshold that differs by race, a complaint system that resolves three percent of complaints, and fourteen written warnings from a supervisor that received no response of any kind.

MORENO-HALE: And with respect, sir — I’d like to answer the hospital question properly, because I think it’s a better question than you intended it to be.

HARCOURT: Go ahead.

MORENO-HALE: If a hospital had a nine percent adverse event rate, we would not say “ninety-one percent of our doctors are fine.” We would not identify the individual doctor and fire him and declare the problem solved. We would look at the protocol, the training, the handoff procedures, the staffing ratios, and the incentive structure. We would assume that a system producing a nine percent failure rate is a system, not a coincidence of bad individuals.

MORENO-HALE: That is the entire argument of my report, Congressman. I am not asking you to believe that American police officers are bad people. I’m asking you to apply to policing the same systems analysis we apply to every other field where people can be killed by a mistake.

There was a pause of several seconds.

HARCOURT: That’s a fair answer. I don’t agree with all of your conclusions but that’s a fair answer, and I’ll say for the record that I appreciate you not pretending my question was stupid.

MORENO-HALE: It wasn’t stupid, sir. It’s the question I’d ask.

That exchange was clipped and posted by both sides as a victory, which is usually a sign that something real happened.

Ryan Caldwell was not called.

He watched the hearing at home, on a Tuesday, in the fourteenth month, with his phone propped against the sugar bowl.

He heard the paragraph about himself — he is twenty-six years old in that footage, he is not evil, he is the product of a system — and he put the phone face down and held the edge of the sink.

He had expected to feel exonerated.

What he felt instead was something he could not name for several days, until he described it to the therapist he had started seeing in month nine, and she said, “That sounds like grief,” and he said, “For what?”, and she said, “For the version of this where you were just a bad guy. That one’s simpler. In that one you get to be punished and then it’s over.”

The arbitration happened in month sixteen, in a hotel conference room, with no cameras.

Donnelly made three arguments.

The first was that the department had never trained Caldwell on the standard it was now firing him for. He put the academy hours into evidence. Eight hours of constitutional law. Ninety minutes of practical Fourth Amendment instruction. He put in Reyes’s recommendation for extended field training and the three-sentence memo denying it.

The second was disparate discipline: he identified nine officers in six years who had made materially false statements in reports and received suspensions ranging from three to fifteen days.

The third was that the city had decided to fire Caldwell on the Monday the video hit nine million views, and had announced it on the Wednesday, and that no investigation had been completed in between.

He won two of the three.

The arbitrator’s ruling, twenty-two pages, found that the termination had been procedurally defective and that the penalty was inconsistent with past practice. He ordered that Caldwell’s termination be converted to a one-hundred-and-eighty-day unpaid suspension, with reinstatement to a non-patrol assignment and mandatory retraining.

The ruling also contained a paragraph that Donnelly did not expect and did not appeal:

The Union’s case is strong on process and weak on substance. The Grievant made a materially false statement on a recorded encounter and has admitted making similar statements on a number of prior occasions that he is unable to quantify. That the Department failed to train him, failed to supervise him, and in fact rewarded the behavior does not transform the behavior into something other than what it was. The Grievant is reinstated because this Department did not earn the right to fire him for a problem it manufactured. He should not mistake that for vindication, and based on his testimony before me, I do not believe he will.

Caldwell read that paragraph in Donnelly’s car in a parking garage.

He read it four times.

Then he said, “Frank, I’m not going back.”

Donnelly, who had spent sixteen months and something over four hundred unbilled hours on this, was quiet for a moment.

“You sure?”

“Yeah.”

“You understand that’s the whole thing. That’s what we were fighting for.”

“I know.”

Donnelly looked out the windshield at a concrete pillar.

“Can I ask why?”

Caldwell thought about it. He had thought about little else for two months.

“Because I’d be good at it again,” he said. “That’s the problem. I’d go back and I’d be careful for about a year and I’d be really proud of how careful I was, and then one day it’d be a Tuesday and I’d be tired and somebody would be standing somewhere not doing anything.” He shook his head slowly. “Sarge Vance told me that. He said the day it happens, it feels like Tuesday. I didn’t know what he meant. I know now, and knowing what it feels like isn’t the same as being able to stop it.”

Donnelly nodded slowly.

“That,” he said, “is the single most honest thing I have ever heard a cop say in twenty-nine years, and I wish to God you’d said it somewhere it would do some good.”

News in the same category

A Rookie Cop Aimed a Taser at Two Men on a Park Bench — Then One Said, “Make Sure Your Camera Catches This Part.”

20 Part