Fifty-one said they had told someone.
And on question six, Brandt got the material that ended up, more than the regressions, more than the hit rates, driving the public response to the report — because the report’s authors made the decision, over the objection of two lawyers, to print thirty-one of the answers verbatim, anonymized, in a ten-page appendix with no commentary whatsoever.
A selection:
I’d want him to know I was coming from my mother’s. That’s it. That’s the whole thing. I was coming from my mother’s.
Nothing. I don’t want him to know anything. I want to not think about it.
That my son was in the car and he was six and he asked me afterward if I did something bad and I said no and he said then why did the police come and I didn’t have an answer. I’d want him to know that I didn’t have an answer for my six year old.
He was polite. I want to say that. He was polite the whole time and I still couldn’t sleep that night and I don’t know what to do with both of those being true.
Honestly? Nothing. It’s fine. It happens. You get used to it. (Interviewer note: subject said “you get used to it” three times in a twelve-minute call.)
That I’m a nurse. I had my badge on. He looked right at it.
I’d want to know what he wrote down about me. I think about that. There’s a file somewhere with my name and something he thought about me in it and I’ll never see it.
That I’m not angry. Everybody expects you to be angry. I’m tired. There’s a difference and nobody asks about the second one.
Tell him I voted for the bond measure for the new police academy. Tell him that. I want him to know I’m on his side and he stopped me anyway.
I’d want him to say the words. Not sorry. Just: you didn’t do anything. I waited the whole nineteen minutes for somebody to say you didn’t do anything and nobody did, they just handed back my ID and said have a good night.
That last one was Arthur Bellamy, though the appendix does not say so and Brandt never confirmed it to anyone.
The appendix was nearly cut.
The argument against it was legitimate: it was anecdote, not evidence. It could not be cross-examined. A city lawyer would be entitled to point out that sixty-three self-selected respondents out of three hundred and twelve is not a sample, it is a collection, and that the report’s rigor everywhere else made the appendix look worse by contrast.
Okonkwo, of all people, was the one who insisted on keeping it.
“I have spent four months producing numbers,” she said in the meeting, “and I will defend every one of them, and I will tell you honestly what they can and cannot do. They can tell you that the threshold differs. They cannot tell you what it is like to be on the other side of a threshold. Those are different kinds of knowledge and you need both, and the only reason we treat one as rigorous and the other as soft is that one of them is easier to put in a table.”
She closed her laptop.
“Put it in the back. Label it clearly. Say it is not statistical evidence. But put it in, because somebody is going to read this document who does not care about a logistic regression, and they are going to turn to page one hundred and fifty-eight, and that is where we will reach them.”
It went in.
Page 158.
In the eighteen months after publication, the appendix was reprinted — in full or in part — in forty-one newspapers, read aloud on the floor of two state legislatures, and assigned in an unknown number of criminal justice courses.
Theo Brandt, who was twenty-nine and had assumed he had been given busywork, did not tell anyone for almost a year that the reason he had been so careful with question six was that he had been stopped twice himself, in college, and nobody had ever asked him anything.
Caldwell read the appendix once.
He read it in the municipal annex basement during his administrative duty, on a department computer, on the day the report was published, with a stack of expired permit applications beside him.
He got to the sixth entry and had to stand up and go into the hallway.
He came back. He finished it.
Then he went back to the beginning and read it again, more slowly, and this time he did something that he later described to his therapist as the worst hour of his life and also the only useful one:
He tried to match them.
Three hundred and twelve stops. Thirty-one voices. He went looking for the faces.
He found four, he thought. He was certain about two.
One was the man who had been coming from his mother’s. Caldwell remembered the jacket. He remembered thinking the jacket was too heavy for the weather, and writing subject appeared nervous upon seeing marked unit, and he remembered — and this was the part that made him put his head down on the desk in a basement office at four in the afternoon — that the man had said, at the end, “Thank you, officer,” and that Caldwell had felt good about that. Had driven away feeling that the encounter had gone well. Had counted it.
The nurse he could not place at all, and the fact that he could not place her was somehow worse.
He never looked for the others.
Not because he could not. Because he understood, sitting there, that the exercise could go on forever and that it would start to be about him — about how much he was willing to feel, about the depth of his remorse, about what a serious person he had become.
He wrote one line in a notebook that night, a different notebook from the one in his old locker, and it is the only thing he has ever read aloud in the training room that he did not work on in advance:
Three hundred and twelve people were waiting for me to say “you didn’t do anything,” and I said it eleven times, and I thought I was good at this job. ## Chapter Nine — The Hearing
The congressional hearing was not about Ryan Caldwell.
It was about federal oversight authority, and it had been scheduled three months before anybody had heard of Riverside Park, and it would have been a sparsely attended Tuesday morning affair covered by two trade publications.
Instead there were four television cameras and a line in the hallway at seven in the morning.
Alicia Moreno-Hale testified for two hours and forty minutes.
She was, by the assessment of nearly everyone who watched it, unexciting in a way that turned out to be devastating. She did not raise her voice. She did not make a single memorable attack. She answered hostile questions as though they were sincere, which had the effect of making the hostile ones sound worse and the sincere ones sound better.
The exchange everyone remembers came ninety minutes in, from a representative from Ohio named Dale Harcourt, who was a former prosecutor and who had done his homework.
HARCOURT: Ms. Moreno-Hale, I want to be fair to you. I’ve read your report. It’s thorough. My problem is the operation itself. You put two men on a bench to see if a police officer would do something wrong. Isn’t that entrapment?