A Rookie Cop Aimed a Taser at Two Men on a Park Bench — Then One Said, “Make Sure Your Camera Catches This Part.”

Chapter 12

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The city attorney’s office had sent two people by six. The chief’s executive officer had arrived by six-thirty. Someone had put a laminated sign on the door of the roll call room that said NO PERSONAL DEVICES, which nobody obeyed.

And the spreadsheet was gone.

Caldwell noticed it on his way past: a clean rectangle on the painted door where the tape had been, slightly brighter than the paint around it, and four small curls of adhesive at the corners.

He stood looking at it for eleven seconds.

Somebody, at some point that afternoon, between 4:00 and 7:00 p.m., had walked down the hall with a purpose and taken it down.

Nobody ever admitted to it. The DOJ asked. Three separate people were interviewed. All three said they assumed somebody else had done it.

In the findings report it occupies one sentence on page 112:

At approximately 1800 hours on the day of the incident, the performance comparison sheet posted in the Precinct Four muster room was removed. The Department was unable to identify who removed it. It was not reposted.

Of all the sentences in that document, that is the one Alicia Moreno-Hale would later say she was proudest of, because of everything it implies without asserting: that somebody in that building knew exactly what the spreadsheet was, knew exactly how it would read to a federal investigator, and knew it fast.

Which means they had always known.

Union representative Frank Donnelly arrived at 7:40 p.m., sixty-three years old, in a Members Only jacket he had owned since the first Bush administration.

He sat Caldwell down in a storage room because every other room was occupied, moved a box of traffic cones off a chair, and said:

“Before you say one word. Did you touch him?”

“No.”

“Did you deploy?”

“No.”

“Did anybody get hurt?”

“No.”

Donnelly exhaled. “Okay. Then you’ve got a case. It’s a bad case, but it’s a case.” He took out a legal pad. “Now. Tell me about the complaint you said you got.”

Caldwell looked at the traffic cones.

“There wasn’t one.”

Donnelly wrote nothing for a long moment.

Then he put the cap back on his pen.

“Son,” he said, “I have represented officers in this city for twenty-nine years. I have defended men I personally believed were guilty as hell and I slept fine, because that’s the job and everybody’s entitled to it.” He leaned forward. “I’m going to represent you all the way to the end of this, and I’m going to work hard at it. But I’m going to tell you right now, so that you hear it from somebody on your side first: the thing you just told me is the thing that makes this unwinnable in public. Not in arbitration. In public. You understand the difference?”

“No.”

“You will,” Donnelly said. “Arbitration I might win. Public, you lost at four o’clock this afternoon and you don’t know it yet because it hasn’t posted.”

It posted at 9:14 the next morning. ## Chapter Six — Nine Million Strangers

The first thing that happens when a city becomes a video is that the city stops being able to talk about anything else.

By Friday noon, every television in every waiting room in the metropolitan area was showing the same four minutes and nine seconds on a loop, with the sound off and a crawl underneath. By Friday evening, the mayor’s communications director had cancelled a ribbon-cutting. By Saturday morning, there were news trucks on three sides of Riverside Park and a man selling bottled water out of a cooler to the camera crews, which is how you know a story has arrived.

The department’s first statement went out at 11:40 Friday morning. It was ninety-one words long and it contained the phrase the totality of the circumstances, which is a phrase that has never once in the history of American public relations made anybody feel better.

The second statement, at 4:15 the same afternoon, was four hundred words and announced that the officer involved had been placed on administrative duty pending review. It did not name him. It did not need to; the internet had done that by one o’clock, along with his high school, his home street, and a photograph from his cousin’s wedding in which he was holding a plate of cake.

The third statement came Monday and was signed personally by Chief Eleanor Voss.

It was the one that changed things, and not in the direction anybody expected.

Eleanor Voss was fifty-eight and had been chief for three years, hired from outside after a scandal involving an evidence room. She was widely regarded as competent, politically careful, and almost pathologically disinclined to say anything interesting in public.

Her Monday statement was eleven paragraphs.

The first nine were what everyone expected: concern, review, cooperation with federal authorities, the dedication of the men and women, et cetera.

The tenth paragraph said this:

I have now watched the video eleven times. I would like to say that what I saw was an aberration. I have spent the weekend reviewing data that I asked for on Friday and have had since Saturday morning, and I am not able to say that honestly. I will not stand in front of this city and tell it something I do not believe.

The eleventh paragraph said:

The Department will not contest the Department of Justice’s request for a pattern or practice investigation. We will not litigate access to our records. I have instructed our counsel to provide everything requested, without a protective order, and to do it within thirty days rather than ninety.

The police union’s response was published eighty minutes later and used the word betrayal four times.

Two city council members called for Voss’s resignation by Tuesday.

A different two called her the most courageous public official in the state.

An editorial in the city’s remaining daily newspaper ran under the headline The Chief Told the Truth. Now What? and argued, correctly as it turned out, that the hardest part was not going to be the admission but the eighteen months after it, when the cameras left and the work was all paperwork.

Priya Raghavan did not want to be famous.

News in the same category

A Rookie Cop Aimed a Taser at Two Men on a Park Bench — Then One Said, “Make Sure Your Camera Catches This Part.”

20 Part