CALDWELL: (pause) When you say it like that.
LINDQVIST: I’m not trying to trick you. I’m asking whether there’s a behavior that would tell you someone is not worth stopping.
CALDWELL: (pause of 14 seconds) I don’t know.
LINDQVIST: Take your time.
CALDWELL: (pause) No. I don’t think there is.
Lindqvist wrote in his notes, in the margin, a single word that was later disclosed in discovery and that a journalist found and published.
The word was: honest.
At hour four, they reached the park.
Lindqvist asked why Caldwell had said there was a complaint.
Caldwell looked at Donnelly. Donnelly looked at the table and said nothing, which was its own kind of advice.
“Because they weren’t going to answer me otherwise,” Caldwell said.
“Was that true when you said it?”
“No.”
“Did you understand at the time that it was not true?”
“Yes.”
“Have you said it before, in other stops, when it was not true?”
The room was very quiet.
“Yes.”
“Approximately how many times?”
“I don’t know.”
“More than ten?”
“Yes.”
“More than fifty?”
A long pause.
“I don’t know. Probably.”
Lindqvist nodded slowly and wrote for a while.
Then he said, “Officer Caldwell, I want to ask you one more thing and then we’ll break. When Mr. Miles said ‘Make sure your camera catches this part’ — what did you think he meant?”
Caldwell said, “I thought he was threatening me.”
“With what?”
“I don’t know. A lawsuit. Embarrassment. I thought he was going to try to make me look bad.”
“And what did he actually mean?”
Caldwell was silent for a long moment.
“He meant it was already over,” he said. “And he was telling me so I could stop.” ## Chapter Eight — Three Hundred and Twelve People
In month eight, a junior analyst named Theo Brandt was assigned the least glamorous task on the project.
The team had the numbers. They had the taxonomy of justifications, the hit rates, the complaint data. What they did not have was any sense of what a stop was like for the person stopped, because the records only contained one side of it, and the one side was written by the person doing the stopping.
So Brandt was given a list of three hundred and twelve names — every person Officer Ryan Caldwell had stopped on his own initiative in his second year — and told to try to reach them.
He reached 104.
Forty-one declined to speak.
Sixty-three agreed.
He spoke to all sixty-three himself, mostly by phone, a few in person, over nine weeks. The interviews were short by design: six questions, never more than fifteen minutes, because he had learned in the first week that long interviews got refusals and short ones got honesty.
The six questions were:
- Do you remember the stop?
- Were you told why?
- How long did it last?
- Did anything happen afterward?
- Did you tell anyone about it?
- Is there anything you’d want the officer to know?
Of the 63:
Fifty-eight remembered it. Brandt had expected far fewer; the interviews were between one and two years after the fact and nothing had happened in any of them.
Eleven said they had been told a reason they understood.
The median estimated duration was twelve minutes. The median recorded duration, from the department’s own data, was seven. Brandt noted this in the report without interpretation, though Okonkwo added a footnote observing that the gap was itself a finding.
Four said something had happened afterward. In three of the four, it was a warning citation. In the fourth, a man had missed a shift and been written up at work.