“Where would that be?”
Donnelly started the car.
“I’ll think about it,” he said.
He did think about it.
Eleven weeks later, Frank Donnelly made a phone call that cost him two friendships and most of his standing in the union hall he had worked out of since 1996.
He called Alicia Moreno-Hale.
“I’ve got something for you,” he said. “You’re not going to like how it’s packaged.” ## Chapter Ten — The Decree
The consent decree was signed on a Thursday in late March, eleven months after the park.
It was 94 pages. It covered stop documentation, supervisory review, early intervention thresholds, complaint intake, use-of-force reporting, training hours, data publication, and the appointment of an independent monitor for a minimum of five years.
There was a press conference. Chief Voss spoke for four minutes. The mayor spoke for nine, which was five minutes too many. Moreno-Hale spoke for ninety seconds and took no questions.
Almost nothing in it was new. Consent decrees are a genre, and like all genres, most of the content is inherited.
Four provisions were unusual enough to be discussed in law reviews.
The first was the written-response requirement, built out of Patrice Ndiaye’s box: every supervisory concern submitted in writing gets a written disposition in thirty days, logged and auditable. Nineteen words of operative text. The city’s lawyers fought it for six weeks, arguing it would generate “an unmanageable volume of paper.”
Moreno-Hale’s response in the negotiation, which leaked, was: “You have told me that if you were required to answer your own sergeants in writing, your department would drown. I want you to hear that sentence again.”
The second was the hit-rate provision: the department must publish, quarterly, the contraband recovery rate for discretionary searches, disaggregated by race, precinct, and — this was the part that caused real panic — by individual officer, with officers identified by a persistent anonymized ID rather than by name.
The anonymized ID was the compromise. The union had refused names. Okonkwo had argued that names were unnecessary and the ID was actually better, because it allowed longitudinal tracking without turning each quarter into a public shaming.
Within eighteen months, three other cities had copied the provision verbatim.
The third was the complaint form. The decree required removal of the criminal-penalty warning from the signature block, relocation to a separate page, acceptance of complaints by phone, online, mail, and in person, and acceptance of anonymous complaints. It also prohibited any communication with a complainant regarding potential criminal exposure except by an attorney.
The laminated card was destroyed. There is a photograph of it in a shredder bin that somebody at the department took and sent to Moreno-Hale with no message attached.
The fourth was the one nobody saw coming, and it was not in the original draft.
It was called, in the decree, Section 11.4: Non-Enforcement Encounter Training, and it required that every officer complete sixteen hours annually of instruction specifically on when not to initiate a contact.
Not de-escalation. Not bias training.
Sixteen hours on the decision not to walk over.
The curriculum had to include, by name, “analysis of recorded encounters in which an officer elected to disengage.”
That provision existed because of a phone call Frank Donnelly made in a parking garage, and because of a man who had decided not to go back.
Ryan Caldwell resigned effective the last day of his suspension.
He did not do interviews. He turned down a book agent, two documentary crews, and a cable program that offered him four thousand dollars to sit on a panel with a man who had been shot by police, which he found so grotesque that he did not answer the email.
What he did instead, starting about five months after the arbitration, was sit in a chair in a classroom at the regional training academy, twice a month, for two hours, in front of between twelve and thirty recruits, and answer questions.
It was not his idea. It was not Donnelly’s either, in the end; Donnelly had pitched something much more public and Moreno-Hale had said no.
The format, which Caldwell and a curriculum designer named Yusuf Bennani worked out over four months of arguments, was this:
They watch the video. All four minutes and nine seconds, no commentary, lights on.
Then they watch it again, stopping at eleven marked points. At each stop, Caldwell says what he was thinking at that moment, as precisely as he can.
Then the recruits ask him anything they want for ninety minutes, and he is not permitted to refuse a question, and he is not permitted to defend himself.
That last rule is Bennani’s, and it is the rule that makes the whole thing work.
“The first version,” Bennani said later, “he kept explaining. Totally understandable. Every third sentence was ‘what you have to understand is.’ And I watched the room and the room went to sleep, because the second you explain, you’ve given them permission to argue with you, and if they’re arguing they’re not looking at themselves. So I told him: you can describe and you can admit. You cannot explain. He hated it for about three months. Then he got good at it.”
The questions recruits ask, in rough order of frequency:
Were you scared? (Yes. Not of them. Of how it would look if I backed off.)
Why didn’t you just walk away? (Because I had already said too many sentences I couldn’t take back. Every one of them made the next one easier and the exit harder.)
What would you have done if they weren’t federal? (I would have cuffed them. They’d have spent a night in county. The charge would have been dropped in eleven days and nobody would ever have heard about it. That’s what makes it bad, not what makes it okay.)
Do you think you’re racist? — this one always comes from somebody near the back, usually in the second hour, usually after a long silence.
And Caldwell’s answer, which he worked on for a year and a half and which still does not satisfy him:
“I don’t know how to answer that in a way that’s useful to you, and I’ve thought about it more than anything else in my life. Here’s the closest I can get.
“I never in my life thought a person was worth less because of their race. I’d have fought you over it. I still would.
“And I stopped three hundred and twelve people in a year, and seventy-one percent of them were Black or Hispanic in a precinct that’s thirty-four percent Black or Hispanic, and I did not notice. Not once. Nobody made me do it. Nobody told me to. I did it by myself, all year, while believing the exact opposite about who I was.
“So if ‘racist’ means a man who hates people, then no, and I’ll say that under oath.