A Rookie Cop Aimed a Taser at Two Men on a Park Bench — Then One Said, “Make Sure Your Camera Catches This Part.”

Chapter 8

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Every department has them, and every department insists they are not quotas, and in the narrow legal sense this is usually true. Nobody at Precinct Four ever told Caldwell he had to make a certain number of stops.

What happened instead was subtler and far more effective.

Twice a month, a spreadsheet was printed and taped inside the door of the roll call room. It listed every officer on the squad and, beside each name, four columns: calls cleared, self-initiated contacts, field interview cards submitted, arrests.

It was not ranked. It did not need to be. Human beings rank things automatically; that is simply what we do with a list.

Caldwell’s first month, he was eleventh out of fourteen.

He hated it with a violence that surprised him.

By his fourth month he was third. By his eighth he was first, and he stayed first for most of a year, and the spreadsheet began to feel less like a measurement and more like a scoreboard, and the scoreboard began to feel less like a scoreboard and more like a mirror.

Here is what nobody told him, because nobody in the building actually knew it:

Of Caldwell’s 312 self-initiated contacts in his second year, 287 produced nothing at all. Not a citation, not an arrest, not a report. Twenty-two produced a minor citation. Three produced an arrest, two of which were dismissed and one of which pled to a misdemeanor.

By any meaningful measure, the strategy did not work.

But “did not work” is invisible when the thing you count is the attempt.

And there is a second number, which the DOJ’s statisticians would eventually extract from the department’s own data and put on page 63 of the findings report, in a table with a plain gray border:

Of those 312 contacts, 71 percent involved Black or Latino subjects, in a precinct whose residential population was 34 percent Black and Latino.

Caldwell, shown that table in a conference room, would say, honestly and with real confusion: “That can’t be right.”

And the statistician, a mild woman in her forties named Dr. Okonkwo who had spent four months inside the department’s records system, would turn the page and say: “I thought you’d say that. Here’s the same analysis for every officer in your squad. You’re not an outlier, Officer Caldwell. You’re the median.”

There were three complaints against him before Riverside Park.

The first, in his tenth month, came from a man named Arthur Bellamy, sixty-one, a retired school custodian, who had been stopped while walking home from a convenience store at 11 p.m. because, according to the field interview card, he “appeared to be checking parked vehicles.”

Mr. Bellamy had been looking for his own car, which his nephew had borrowed and parked somewhere on the block.

He was detained for nineteen minutes. He was not arrested. He wrote a two-page complaint in careful cursive on lined paper.

The complaint was classified as Not Sustained, which in that department meant: insufficient evidence to prove or disprove.

The investigator had reviewed the body camera footage and written: Officer’s conduct was professional in tone throughout.

Which was true. Caldwell had been perfectly polite for all nineteen minutes.

Nobody asked whether the nineteen minutes should have happened.

The second complaint, at fourteen months, was from a woman who said Caldwell had searched her vehicle after she told him no. The footage showed her saying “I guess” after Caldwell said, “You don’t have anything in here I need to worry about, right? You mind if I take a look? It’ll be quick, then you’re on your way.”

Classified: Exonerated. Consent obtained.

The third, at twenty months, was from a nineteen-year-old named Marcus Teale, who said Caldwell had put him against a wall for nothing.

That one was withdrawn. The file notes that the complainant “declined to pursue.”

What the file does not note is that Marcus Teale’s mother had called the precinct twice to ask about the status, and on the second call had been told, by a civilian clerk who was reading from a card, that the investigation could take up to a year, that her son might be asked to testify, and that if any portion of the complaint were found to be knowingly false, he could face charges.

Every word of that was technically accurate.

Marcus Teale withdrew his complaint the next day.

He was, four years later, a plaintiff in the class action.

On the Tuesday before Riverside Park, Sergeant Daniel Vance called Caldwell into the small office with the broken blinds.

Vance was fifty-one and had been a sergeant for nine years and would have been a lieutenant if he had been better at the parts of the job that happen in rooms with carpet.

“Sit down.”

Caldwell sat.

“Your numbers are good.”

“Thank you, Sarge.”

“That wasn’t a compliment, it was a sentence.” Vance leaned back. The chair complained. “Quality over quantity, kid. You’re making a lot of contacts and you’re not bringing in much. That tells me one of two things. Either you’re unlucky, or you’re stopping people who shouldn’t be stopped.”

Caldwell felt his face go hot. “I’m working my beat.”

“I know you are.” Vance rubbed his eyes. “Look. I’m not writing you up. I’m telling you something because somebody told me once and I didn’t listen for about six years. The day the stop becomes about whether you can make the person answer you — that’s the day you’ve stopped being a cop and started being something else. And the worst part is it doesn’t feel like anything. It feels like Tuesday.”

Caldwell said, “Yes, Sergeant.”

He walked out of the office and down the hall and he was angry, and the anger had a specific flavor he recognized from childhood: the burn of being told you are doing the thing you are most proud of wrong.

He made nine contacts on Wednesday.

He made three on Thursday morning.

And at 3:47 on Thursday afternoon, driving past the north end of Riverside Park, with Vance’s voice still in his ear and the spreadsheet still taped to the door of the roll call room, he saw two men sitting on a bench doing absolutely nothing.

And it bothered him. ## Chapter Four — The Men on the Bench

News in the same category

A Rookie Cop Aimed a Taser at Two Men on a Park Bench — Then One Said, “Make Sure Your Camera Catches This Part.”

20 Part