That is the thing nobody says often enough about young officers. Most of them start out wanting the same thing. They want to matter. They want the thing they do all day to be the thing that stands between somebody and the worst night of their life.
What happens to that wanting is the entire question.
The academy was twenty-six weeks.
Caldwell did well. He was in the top quarter academically and the top ten percent physically. He was quiet, which instructors read as discipline. He asked questions, which instructors read as engagement. He was voted by his class to carry the colors at graduation, and his mother cried, and his father shook his hand and said “Good job, bud,” which from him was an oration.
Of those twenty-six weeks:
Seventy-two hours were firearms.
Sixty hours were defensive tactics.
Forty hours were emergency vehicle operations.
Twenty-four hours were criminal law, which in practice meant elements of offenses — what you need to charge someone, what makes a case stick.
Eight hours were constitutional law.
Eight.
And of those eight, roughly ninety minutes addressed the Fourth Amendment in any practical way, and that ninety minutes was taught by a sergeant from the training division who was a decent man and a terrible teacher, and who opened the block with a joke that got a laugh every single time he told it:
“All right, Fourth Amendment. The rule is: don’t search stuff you’re not allowed to search. Any questions? Great, let’s talk about inventory searches, because that’s the one you’ll actually use.”
Four hours were de-escalation.
Two hours were implicit bias, delivered by a vendor over a video link, with a quiz at the end that everyone passed because the quiz was designed so that everyone would pass it.
Sixteen hours were report writing, which was, Caldwell would later reflect, the only part of the curriculum that treated the job as something you have to justify to another human being afterward.
These numbers are not unusual. They are not even bad, by the standards of the profession in that state in that year. The DOJ’s eventual findings report would note, in a footnote that almost nobody read, that the department’s academy met or exceeded state minimum standards in every category.
The footnote ended with one sentence that several commentators called the most devastating line in the entire 171-page document:
The standards are the problem.
Field training was sixteen weeks with three different officers.
The first was Sofia Reyes, twenty-two years on, bad knee, no interest in being liked. She drove with one wrist draped over the top of the wheel and she made Caldwell narrate everything.
“What do you see?”
“Guy on the corner.”
“That’s not what I asked. What do you see.”
“Male, thirties, standing at the bus stop.”
“Is there a bus coming?”
Caldwell checked the sign. “Eleven minutes.”
“So he’s a guy waiting for a bus.” She pulled through the light. “You want to stop him?”
“No.”
“Why not?”
“Because he’s waiting for a bus.”
“Right.” She tapped the wheel twice. “Say that out loud as many times as you need to. Ninety-five percent of this job is noticing something and then deciding it’s nothing. That’s the skill. Anybody can notice. The skill is the deciding.”
Caldwell had liked Reyes. He had also found her exhausting. Every shift with her felt like an oral exam he was failing slowly.
In week five she wrote in his log: Trainee reads stillness as a threat. Will need work.
She also wrote, in the comment box of the formal evaluation: Recommend extended FTO period. Strong instincts for officer safety, weak instincts for proportionality. This is fixable now and will not be fixable later.
The extended FTO period was denied. The division was eleven officers short. The staffing memo explaining the denial is three sentences long and is Exhibit 44 in the federal case.
His second FTO was fine. Competent, unremarkable, three years from retirement, mostly interested in getting through the shift.
His third was a man named Brett Sanderson.
Sanderson was thirty-four and had the highest contact numbers in the precinct, by a distance that was not close. He was funny. He was generous with his time. He bought coffee. He remembered the names of people’s kids. Every rookie wanted him and about a third of them got him.
His philosophy, delivered to Caldwell in week twelve while they sat in a lot behind a closed hardware store eating gas station sandwiches, was this:
“Everything out here is a conversation about who’s running the conversation. That’s it. That’s the whole thing. The second you’re not running it, you’re not safe, and the second you’re not safe, somebody else is making decisions about your life. So you run it. Always. Doesn’t matter if it’s a jaywalker or a guy with a gun. Same muscle.”
Caldwell had written that down. Not in the log. In a notebook he kept in his locker, in which he collected sentences that seemed true.
He underlined it.
It is, as it happens, almost exactly wrong — it takes a thing that is occasionally necessary and makes it the organizing principle of every human interaction — but it has the shape of wisdom, and it was delivered by a man who was universally liked, and Caldwell was twenty-four years old.
Then came the numbers.