The horse went down at four o'clock in the afternoon, and Caleb Rourke knew the exact minute of it for
the rest of his life, because his pocket watch stopped in the fall.
Rusty was picking his way down a long grass slope above a creek neither of them had a name for yet,
the sorrel's head low and swinging, tired the way a horse gets tired on the fourth day of a ride he has not
been fed for properly. Caleb was tired too, in the bone-deep way that made a man careless, and later he
would be honest enough to admit that carelessness was the whole of it. He saw the badger hole a half
second before Rusty's near forefoot found it. He had time to say the horse's name, which was no use to
either of them, and then the world came up sideways and hit him in the ribs with the whole weight of
Montana.
They rolled once, together, in a tangle of rein and stirrup leather and flying turf. Caleb came loose on
the second turn and fetched up against a stone with his breath knocked clean out of him, and lay there
looking at a sky so blue and indifferent that it seemed to be making a point.
Rusty got up. That was the first mercy. He got up blowing hard, shook himself, and stood threelegged with the near fore cocked and trembling, and Caleb, who had come up the trail from Texas with
two horses and buried one of colic outside Fort Benton, sat in the grass and felt the particular loneliness
of a man down to one horse and watching that one hold a leg off the ground.
"Easy," he said. "Easy, partner. Let me look before we both get dramatic."
The leg was not broken through. He ran his hands down it the way his father had taught him before
he could read, knuckle by knuckle, and found the heat low on the cannon and a swelling already rising
under the skin like bread. Strained, maybe cracked fine as a hair. Not a leg a horse could travel on. Not a
leg a horse could be left standing on in open country either, with the nights coming down cold the way
they did in this high country in October.
Caleb unloaded him there on the slope. Saddle, bedroll, saddlebags with four days of coffee and bacon
and a book wrapped in oilcloth, the Winchester in its scabbard. He built the pile neat, because neatness
was a habit that had kept him alive in worse places than this, and then he stood a while with his hand on
Rusty's neck and took stock of the valley the way a man takes stock of a hand of cards he did not ask to
be dealt.
It was a good valley, and that was the trouble with it. Good land never stayed empty, and emptylooking land in Montana in 1884 was usually just land whose owners were not standing where you
could see them. The creek ran green and willow-hung out of a notch in the western hills. Cottonwoods
stood in a long line along it, going gold. Above the creek on the north side there were meadows that had
the combed look of ground that gets grazed and rested in turns, which meant somebody's herd, which
meant somebody. To the south the valley shouldered up into timber and then into bare rock, and in the
notch where the creek came down there was a thread of smoke, standing straight up in the still air,
patient as a held breath.
Caleb looked at the smoke a long time.
He was three days out of the settlements, bound for Fort Shaw, where a letter from a man he had
scouted with in '77 said there was winter work for a man who could read, write a fair hand, and talk
some Apache and more Crow. It was the kind of work a man took when the cattle money ran out and the
winter came on with its hand open. He had ridden this cut-off because the freight road swung twenty
miles wide around these hills and he had been, as usual, in a hurry to arrive at a life he had not properly
chosen.
Now the life would have to wait. A man afoot in this country in October, leading a three-legged
horse, had a range of about as far as he could see, and what he could see was a valley with smoke in it.
He watered Rusty from his hat at the creek, a hatful at a time, and the horse drank and sighed and put his
nose against Caleb's chest in the old way, asking after the plan.
"Plan is we walk toward the smoke, partner," Caleb said. "Slow. Whoever owns that fire owns this
valley, and I'd rather meet them in daylight, on my feet, with my hat in my hand, than have them find
your bones and my tracks in the spring and wonder."
He took the Winchester out of the scabbard and then, after a moment, put it back and buckled the
flap. He slung the saddlebags over his own shoulder, took up the lead rope, and they started down the
long slope at the pace of the horse's worst step, which was a pace that gave a man a great deal of time to
think.
He thought about the watch first, because it was in his hand. It had been his father's, a heavy silver
thing that had survived the war and two cattle fortunes and the losing of both, and when Caleb shook it
he heard the small dry rattle of something inside come loose from its moorings. Four-ten, the hands said,